southstandandy
WEST STAND ANDY
- Jul 9, 2003
- 6,047
A £50 fine, slap on the wrist, and a one week ban on playing Blue Moon is all that will happen.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Football] Man City PL Charges
- Thread starter Beach Hut
- Start date
Something akin to this . . . . . . . The baddies win because they can afford to.
How oligarchs took on the UK fraud squad – and won
The long read: It began as a routine investigation into a multinational called ENRC. It became a decade-long saga that has rocked the UK’s financial crime agency. Now new documents illuminate a case that has rewritten UK law and is set to end with a huge bill handed to taxpayers
www.theguardian.com
Odd take. The best / richest clubs have their pick of all the talent, and they chose him - for a reason.
I heard a few weeks ago that they have already spent £20m on lawyers. They'll double that and more when they drag this out through an appeal.
Nobby Cybergoat
Well-known member
- Jul 19, 2021
- 8,624
I think they will be clobbered. I'm calling 50 points. Enough to mean they might go down or might not.
The tricky situation will be the inevitable appeal. I think there will be a situation last year where nobody knows who is actually in the relegation scrap
I also think there will be ban on individuals being directors or involved in football in the PL and a record fine and a costs award.
When you look at the charges against them, they are pretty bad
The tricky situation will be the inevitable appeal. I think there will be a situation last year where nobody knows who is actually in the relegation scrap
I also think there will be ban on individuals being directors or involved in football in the PL and a record fine and a costs award.
When you look at the charges against them, they are pretty bad
I know. But in Soccernomics by Simon Culver and some other bod the data kind of suggests that the coach isn’t that important.
I think ‘The Numbers Game’ might suggest something similar.
I was reading recently about City's way of doing things. I think it was 2018/19, City submitted their accounts but provided no documentary evidence to support their figures. PL said you must provide evidence and City said you have no jurisdiction to ask us for that. It went to court about a year later, PL won. City applied for leave to appeal which was granted, another year later in High Court they lost again. As part of the appeal the PL said they would be setting up an independent tribunal to deal with such charges. City took the PL to court about this, saying it wouldn't be independent as the PL were setting it up. They lost again. Again they appealed against decision and lost again. This whole process took about 4 years.
The lawyers are rubbing their hands together with glee.
You join a club, you play by the rules of the club. Or simply, leave the club. Your choice Man City.
Hotchilidog
Well-known member
- Jan 24, 2009
- 9,120
I've said it before, but I think City will get a points deduction that will relegate them to the Championship. Given all the they have gained through their consistent rule breaking this will effectively just be a slap on the wrist as they will bounce back immediately and then resume normal service back in the premier league a season later. This will not stop them whining about the injustice of it all though.
Relegation to tier 4, with a 5 year ban from playing in the EPL (so they may enjoy a couple of futile years winning the championship and not being promoted) would be fun.
FatSuperman
Well-known member
- Feb 25, 2016
- 2,922
This is the sort of thing there must already be a yougov vote for
nwgull
Well-known member
I hope they get a significant sanction that prevents their ongoing dominance. As has been posted above, the PL is in danger of becoming like the Scottish Premiership. This would also have the benefit of setting a precedent so Chelsea will be f***ed as well.
Could open up a whole can of worms though. How much of a case for loss of income might clubs have that finished just outside of the Champions League spots during the seasons they are found to have broken the rules in?
Could open up a whole can of worms though. How much of a case for loss of income might clubs have that finished just outside of the Champions League spots during the seasons they are found to have broken the rules in?
Probably the end of football if they are seen to have broken the rules and don't get properly (more than a points deduction) punished. The charges are pretty full on, I'm not sure other clubs would be too pleased if they just don't participate in the Champions League one season. As a certain pocaster says, it's corporate fraud some of it.
Wes Tupper
Active member
- Feb 27, 2024
- 117
If found guilty by the panel of false accounting, are legal proceedings likely to ensue?
No accounting rules broken, PL rules are different.
My biggest fear is that opportunist DULLARDS will be boring the whole country to death on the matter on TV and radio and frankly, after a tough year for the country with the Farage riots it is the last thing we need.
KZNSeagull
Well-known member
TL;DL
I've always thought they would get hammered as the PL has invested so much time with this
Plus if they are seen to get away with it, the PL will be damaged beyond repair
I imagine Levy/bloom/kroenke/FSG etc would all consider action if they PL are seen to let them off
Plus if they are seen to get away with it, the PL will be damaged beyond repair
I imagine Levy/bloom/kroenke/FSG etc would all consider action if they PL are seen to let them off
el punal
Well-known member
Pie in the sky this one so bear with me. Suppose that Man City got away with all charges levelled against them despite all the evidence to the contrary. City lawyers outlawyered the authorities with Shyster & Shyster shenanigans which ends up with a proverbial slap on the wrist. Here comes the what if bit.
What if the remaining 19 Premier League clubs then decide en masse to refuse to play Man City in protest? Would each fixture then be declared null and void, or, would City then be awarded 3 points for each cancelled match? If the answer is the former then City would accrue nul points throughout the season, or if the latter, 114 points without a ball being kicked.
Okay, so a completely farcical response to what is fast becoming a farcical situation. I just hope and pray that justice is served and that cheats are punished good n’ proper. Not too much to ask for is it?
What if the remaining 19 Premier League clubs then decide en masse to refuse to play Man City in protest? Would each fixture then be declared null and void, or, would City then be awarded 3 points for each cancelled match? If the answer is the former then City would accrue nul points throughout the season, or if the latter, 114 points without a ball being kicked.
Okay, so a completely farcical response to what is fast becoming a farcical situation. I just hope and pray that justice is served and that cheats are punished good n’ proper. Not too much to ask for is it?
wardy wonder land
Active member
- Dec 10, 2007
- 791
that would give the arsenal wet-wipes another massive moan-fest ! loosing the "inviciables" tag to ManC !!!