[Politics] Labour Party meltdown incoming.......

Pavilionaire said:

I expect Labour to win the Commons vote, for Winter Fuel Payments to be scrapped and for everybody to move on. However, Labour's PR chief needs sacking.

To my mind, Labour should have had their Budget at the earliest opportunity, which would have been c. 12/13 September. They could have kept schtum until then, unleashed all the pain and taken all the negativity in one hit. But at least there would have been certainty moving forward, businesses, investors and the housing market could start planning and party conference could take the new plans into account and develop policy.

Instead, we've had Starmer's speech saying there will be great pain, then we've had this Winter Fuel Payment story, and we still have to wait another 7 weeks before the actual Budget.

This is spreading the pain and negativity over an extended period, one in which 5 Tory candidates for the leadership can each have a pop at Labour and magnify the Opposition response. In addition, Labour will be trying to end the public sector strikes with wage hikes but no one knows where the money is coming from, fanning the flames of uncertainty.

Labour have created a economic policy vacuum and it is not helping them. Maybe they should get Mandelson and Alistair Campbell back to sort this PR shitshow out?

Click to expand...

Guinness Boy said:

We will agree to disagree and that's fine. Earlier in the thread I was discussing this with two mates and I'm sure we'd put the same views over if we were talking over a pint.

My point, really is that there is a black hole to fix AND public services (e.g. NHS, Education, Transport) that are in parlous states following Tory neglect, Brexit and the pandemic. Everyone agrees they need fixing but no one wants THEIR money to pay for it. That simply isn't going to work. And, as a follow on, it's perfectly possible that the budget will hit my family too and I'm fine with that if it fixes those issues and leads to sustainable growth. I'd rather that than pay for Boris's wine cellar.

Click to expand...

Guinness Boy said:

We will agree to disagree and that's fine. Earlier in the thread I was discussing this with two mates and I'm sure we'd put the same views over if we were talking over a pint.

My point, really is that there is a black hole to fix AND public services (e.g. NHS, Education, Transport) that are in parlous states following Tory neglect, Brexit and the pandemic. Everyone agrees they need fixing but no one wants THEIR money to pay for it. That simply isn't going to work. And, as a follow on, it's perfectly possible that the budget will hit my family too and I'm fine with that if it fixes those issues and leads to sustainable growth. I'd rather that than pay for Boris's wine cellar.

Click to expand...

Guinness Boy said:

Read the Full Fact link I supplied which will tell you that's not the case.

Click to expand...

Pavilionaire said:

I expect Labour to win the Commons vote, for Winter Fuel Payments to be scrapped and for everybody to move on. However, Labour's PR chief needs sacking.

To my mind, Labour should have had their Budget at the earliest opportunity, which would have been c. 12/13 September. They could have kept schtum until then, unleashed all the pain and taken all the negativity in one hit. But at least there would have been certainty moving forward, businesses, investors and the housing market could start planning and party conference could take the new plans into account and develop policy.

Instead, we've had Starmer's speech saying there will be great pain, then we've had this Winter Fuel Payment story, and we still have to wait another 7 weeks before the actual Budget.

This is spreading the pain and negativity over an extended period, one in which 5 Tory candidates for the leadership can each have a pop at Labour and magnify the Opposition response. In addition, Labour will be trying to end the public sector strikes with wage hikes but no one knows where the money is coming from, fanning the flames of uncertainty.

Labour have created a economic policy vacuum and it is not helping them. Maybe they should get Mandelson and Alistair Campbell back to sort this PR shitshow out?

Click to expand...

beorhthelm said:

i did when checking on the points forming the black hole. they cite the IFS with an estimated 10-20bn hole by end of the parliament, which is largely made from the pay awards. there was no expectation of these large pay awards in the 2021 spending review, because there was underestimated forecast of inflation, and more recently no intention to follow the pay recommendations. that puts it down to policy decisions.

Click to expand...

Weststander said:

I said months ago that Blair had the advantage of Campbell, Mandelson and the like of John Reid. Political bruisers and masters of spin.

Click to expand...

The Clamp said:

I don’t see what the fuss is. Pensioners are actullay going to be better off. But I suppose that’s not sensational enough for some.

“UK state pension could rise by about £460 a year from April, wage growth figures suggest”​

The Guardian
10-09/2024

Click to expand...

RandyWanger said:

Utterly deplorable indeed. #StarmerOut is trending on X

I liked this graphic

Click to expand...

The Clamp said:

Makes more economic sense to stop the strikes and get the country moving again than save well off pensioners £25 a month.

“The government can’t reduce safety on the railways, these people deserve better pay”

Okay. Where does the money come from?


Sorry, nearly all pensioners will be better off and have money left over. They’ll be on 145 quid better off a year.

Stop clutching your pearls. The oldies will be just fine. The rest of the country needs a working railway system and productive workers.

It’s £25 a month. Get over it.

Click to expand...

Mellor 3 Ward 4 said:

Remind me - when do fuel bills go up? Yep, that's right, October.

When does the pension increase kick in? Yep, right again, April.

Might be too late for some pensioners.

Listen to the Charities - non-political -they know this is wrong.
You know this is wrong.
Lots of Labour MPs know this is wrong.

That's because it is wrong.

Click to expand...

Bozza said:

It's remarkable how you can so glibly group 10m people together, and believe that this change won't adversely impact a fair few at the lower end of the income and wealth spectrum.

For the first time ever, because of my mother, I've sought help, advice and support from Age UK. They truly are remarkable in what they do, and their knowledge of those they serve.

So, when I read them saying the following, I sit up and take notice.

We strongly oppose the means-testing of the Winter Fuel Payment because it means as many as 2 million pensioners who badly need the money to stay warm this winter will not receive it and will be in serious trouble as a result.​

​

Means-testing the Winter Fuel Payment, with no notice and no compensatory measures to protect poor and vulnerable pensioners, is the wrong policy choice, and one that will potentially jeopardise the health as well as the finances of millions of older people this winter – the last thing either they or the NHS needs.​

​

This isn't about mansion-dwelling millionaire oldies.

Click to expand...

Pavilionaire said:

I agree. Blair's Labour was a slick machine, they controlled the narrative and the agenda. Crucially, they were ahead of the curve, they could see the problem approaching from a distance and head it off in advance.

This Winter Fuel Payment story should not be getting the traction it has, and has presented the Tories with a quick way of getting back into the game.

In some respects, if Starmer is going to go down this route and be "all substance, no spin" then I kind of admire him, but at the same time there seems to be some political naivety at play.

Click to expand...

Pavilionaire said:

I expect Labour to win the Commons vote, for Winter Fuel Payments to be scrapped and for everybody to move on. However, Labour's PR chief needs sacking.

To my mind, Labour should have had their Budget at the earliest opportunity, which would have been c. 12/13 September. They could have kept schtum until then, unleashed all the pain and taken all the negativity in one hit. But at least there would have been certainty moving forward, businesses, investors and the housing market could start planning and party conference could take the new plans into account and develop policy.

Instead, we've had Starmer's speech saying there will be great pain, then we've had this Winter Fuel Payment story, and we still have to wait another 7 weeks before the actual Budget.

This is spreading the pain and negativity over an extended period, one in which 5 Tory candidates for the leadership can each have a pop at Labour and magnify the Opposition response. In addition, Labour will be trying to end the public sector strikes with wage hikes but no one knows where the money is coming from, fanning the flames of uncertainty.

Labour have created a economic policy vacuum and it is not helping them. Maybe they should get Mandelson and Alistair Campbell back to sort this PR shitshow out?

Click to expand...

The Clamp said:

It’s means tested.

That’s fair.

Sorry if you don’t think so but you’re wrong.

Click to expand...