Who has been our best keeper since 1990

[Brighton Breezy]

What do Flinders, Henderson and Roberts all have in common?

All of them kept Kuipers out of the team.

Now figure out HOW THE HELL Kuipers is ranked numero uno.

 

[chez]

40 people have voted for Kuipers. I thought this was going to be a sensible poll with proper answers!!

 

[cheeseroll]

Keeley was class

 

[Seagullible]

in the end it's opinion. People will have their favourites. I think FDM IS and always has been a better keeper than Hendo but that's my view and the poll is to get a general view of a lot of people hence so many different answers

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

would never remember Beeney or Keeley, and out of the rest Kuipers is clearly the best.

The 29 who have voted for Ben Roberts would seem to disagree

 

[bhafc]

Beaney without question for me

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

41 v 29, you did maths at school didn't you Marcus?

Yes, but you express your statement as fact - "of the rest, Kuipers is clearly the best"

That's your opinion. But i think the man with 6 clean sheets in a row was superior...and the fact that 29 others do would suggest that it's not as 'clear' as you might think

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

One person has voted for Mark Cartwright - doesn't mean he/she is right

nor does it mean he/she is wrong....

Alas, nobody has voted for Packham

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

And in the absence of any definitive proof, you have to accept the view of the majority. .

Says who? Is their a rule saying that the leader of a NSC 'who is best' poll is definitely the best, even if many disagree?


Or is that only when your beloved 'God' is winning?

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

He's not winning you fool, Potter

That's Beeney, but going back to YOUR comment regarding anyone our age or younger, it's Kuipers.

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

Don't move the goalposts to suit your game. You're a FRAUD Potter

Your tactic of avoiding difficult questions that you cannot answer is most London Irish-esque. Still, How fraudulent of ME.


Still, as long as we're all happy that Beeney 'must have been our best ever keeper, with GOD second best, because NSC says so', then there isn't a problem, is there?