Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Whingy to Charlton?
- Thread starter RM-Taylor
- Start date
BensGrandad
New member
I would think that we would let him go on a free and would never expect to get £50k for him even when he came to us and was quite good. Think that may be a typing error and that you put the 0 in by mistake.
BensGrandad
New member
you forgot to add
'enough to expect somebody to pay for Whing.
I hope that somebody in our diviision does sign him so that he can play against us.
Ninja Elephant
Doctor Elephant
- Feb 16, 2009
- 18,855
Congratulations, BG, consistently the most miserable person on this forum.
I hope Whing does find a new club this summer. He is a better player than the waste away in our reserve team, being trotted out to play with the kids every now and then.
I hope Whing does find a new club this summer. He is a better player than the waste away in our reserve team, being trotted out to play with the kids every now and then.
HseagullsH
NSC's tipster
It's quite clear you don't like Whing but the fact remains that he has a two year contract and only the season before he was our player of the season.
He is only 25 so arguably at his peak now.
50k is easily possible.
Here's Johnny!
All work and no play.....
Depends how much of a wage increase he got when we re-negotiated his contract after he got player of the year for as to if we'd be willing to offfload him for free i supose.
Shame for Whing as he played well 2 seasons ago in a really tough year but started last year with that horror own goal on the opening day and never really got his form back again.
Calde is a better player in my book but wish Whingy all the best whatever happens.
** PS dont forget BG a year ago we were all desperate not to lose Whing to Leeds/Huddersfield. He's a good player for this level on his day and deserves more respect than you are showing him.**
Shame for Whing as he played well 2 seasons ago in a really tough year but started last year with that horror own goal on the opening day and never really got his form back again.
Calde is a better player in my book but wish Whingy all the best whatever happens.
** PS dont forget BG a year ago we were all desperate not to lose Whing to Leeds/Huddersfield. He's a good player for this level on his day and deserves more respect than you are showing him.**
Simon Morgan
New member
BensGrandad
New member
Not miserable at all just have the opinion that he is an awful full back who could never command a fee irrespective of his age. When he arrived here he was reasonable and held his own. Was voted player of the season based on about 8 games when he charged around like a mad man when nobody else cared or did anything of note. Is now so far down the pecking order, probably about 5th choice right back behind Calderon, El Abd, Kishishev and Steve Cook that I would think that the club would be pleased for him to find a new club to get him off the wage bill. They paid good money for Jake Wright but let him go for free as he didnt fit in the plans. Gus has already said that he doesnt figure in the plans but he is so professional that he will not force him out.
Nappy thrower
Banned
Complete rubbish. We got rid of Wright for nothing.The first offer for Whing ie free transfer and Poyet will get rid. You start charging a fee for Whing then you can expect him to still be here.He isn't worth anything.
I agree that we should get him off the payroll - but that is disingenuous in the extreme.
its a free transfer he,s been forced out
"forced out"!
Yeah - paulclark in "everything Gus does as a bad thing" shock.
Is it possible he didn't fit with Gus' plans? His game was off? We have better options? Squad needs to be trimmed? No. he was "forced" (note, not even pushed but FORCED) out.
You cock.
Yeah - paulclark in "everything Gus does as a bad thing" shock.
Is it possible he didn't fit with Gus' plans? His game was off? We have better options? Squad needs to be trimmed? No. he was "forced" (note, not even pushed but FORCED) out.
You cock.
severnside gull
Well-known member
Would anyone on here want to see Whing as the last defender against a skilfull attacker, he's made so many errors over the last few seasons, all the effort and running around counts for nothing if he's giving goals away - just get him off the wage bill, very doubtful anyone in this division will pay anything more than a nominal 10k.