Player ratings - Reading

[Acker79]

Averages - 32 votes

Starters
Kuszczak 7.50
Upson 6.83
Ward 6.34
Lingard 6.25 (62min)
Ulloa 6.23
Bruno 6.06
Andrews 5.91
Ince 5.81 (86min)
Forster-Caskey 5.64
David Lopez 5.20 (53min)
Greer 4.95 (52min - 31 votes)


Subs
Buckley 6.58 (35min)
Dunk 6.34 (44min)
March 5.83 (11min - 30 votes)


Squad average - 6.11

 

[big nuts]

Averages - 32 votes

Starters
Kuszczak 7.50
Upson 6.83
Ward 6.34
Lingard 6.25 (62min)
Ulloa 6.23
Bruno 6.06
Andrews 5.91
Ince 5.81 (86min)
Forster-Caskey 5.64
David Lopez 5.20 (53min)
Greer 4.95 (52min - 31 votes)


Subs
Buckley 6.58 (35min)
Dunk 6.34 (44min)
March 5.83 (11min - 30 votes)


Squad average - 6.11

March scoring higher than Forster-Caskey? His only two involvements in eleven minutes were choosing the wrong option on a very promising breakaway and putting us in trouble and then the mis-hit corner, whereas Jake works his backside off for 80 minutes and ends up being slated by the majority.

I like March his going to be class, but it just shows you people have their favourites and their fall guys unfortunately Dave & JFC tend to be on the receiving end of harsher scores than the rest of the squad.

 

[Scunner]

March scoring higher than Forster-Caskey? His only two involvements in eleven minutes were choosing the wrong option on a very promising breakaway and putting us in trouble and then the mis-hit corner, whereas Jake works his backside off for 80 minutes and ends up being slated by the majority.

I like March his going to be class, but it just shows you people have their favourites and their fall guys unfortunately Dave & JFC tend to be on the receiving end of harsher scores than the rest of the squad.

It beggars belief really. Ince and Andrews were so much worse than JFC it isn't true, but myth builds a perception and perception builds a truth even if there is none in it. Subs shouldn't really get a mark unless they've been on more than 10mins imo.

 

[Silk]

I think there may be a very subtle difference between it being "easy to miss" what he contributes, and him actually not contributing much. Personally I think he's on the wrong side of it, but perhaps I'll watch him more closely on Tuesday. If he plays.

I thought he played quite well on Tuesday as it happens.