Parallels with Mcghee at previous clubs

[enigma]

With the exception of Cahill, Ward, Reid and to an extent Ifil, that isnt a great team.

 

[Theatre of Trees]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Parallels with Mcghee at previous clubs

Question for you how many of those players have moved on to bigger clubs?

Cahill to Everton
Reid to Blackburn
Ifill to Sheffield United
Ward to Palace

 

[London Irish]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Parallels with Mcghee at previous clubs

Just out of interest, when did you start watching Brighton?

If I answer this, will you want to know the colour of my underwear next

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Parallels with Mcghee at previous clubs

If I answer this, will you want to know the colour of my underwear next

So I assume you couldnt really comment if I said Andy Ansah was a better player than Mccammon

 

[Theatre of Trees]

I count 8

Who are the other four then? Warner is about to move to Fulham as reserve keeper but he spent a large period of last season out of favour anyway.

Lawrence, Robinson, Phillips, Dunne, Livermore, May and Brannif are all still at the club

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Who are the other four then? Warner is about to move to Fulham as reserve keeper but he spent a large period of last season out of favour anyway.

Lawrence, Robinson, Phillips, Dunne, Livermore, May and Brannif are all still at the club

My bad i thought that was the paul robinson at west brom


Ward - Palace
Ifil - Sheff
Warner - fulham
cahill everton
Reid blackburn
Neil - Blackburn
johnson - chelsea
sweeny - stoke

 

[JSD Albion]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Parallels with Mcghee at previous clubs

So I assume you couldnt really comment if I said Andy Ansah was a better player than Mccammon

I'd definitely say that Andy Ansah was a smaller player than McCammon, and even less likely to score. He was also playing in what was then the third division, so direct comparisons beyond that seem pointless.

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Parallels with Mcghee at previous clubs

I'd definitely say that Andy Ansah was a smaller player than McCammon, and even less likely to score. He was also playing in what was then the third division, so direct comparisons beyond that seem pointless.

Id like to see Mccammon score as many as he got...

 

[enigma]

My bad i thought that was the paul robinson at west brom


Ward - Palace
Ifil - Sheff
Warner - fulham
cahill everton
Reid blackburn
Neil - Blackburn
johnson - chelsea
sweeny - stoke

Dont know how good Sweeney is. Johnson was only on loan.

Dont forget that was a young team. Its easy to say now how good they are, back then many of those were still developing.

 

[JSD Albion]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Parallels with Mcghee at previous clubs

Id like to see Mccammon score as many as he got...

You already have, in an Albion shirt. Three each.

 

[London Irish]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Parallels with Mcghee at previous clubs

You already have, in an Albion shirt. Three each.

Big Mac wins - he has 4

 

[London Irish]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Parallels with Mcghee at previous clubs

So I assume you couldnt really comment if I said Andy Ansah was a better player than Mccammon

Well, only that given you have such as goonish view of McCammon, you would probably think Farrington, Moralee, Mahoney-Johnson and Cameron were all better players too.

 

[Theatre of Trees]

My bad i thought that was the paul robinson at west brom


Ward - Palace
Ifil - Sheff
Warner - fulham
cahill everton
Reid blackburn
Neil - Blackburn
johnson - chelsea
sweeny - stoke

Lucas Neill went in August of that year after playing in 2 games plus 2 subs appearences therefore he had a near enough zilch effect on the play-off campaign.

Glenn Johnson did not play for Millwall during their play-off season but the following season for 7 games.

I'd question whether Sweeney's move to Stoke was an upward one rather than a sideways move and he's only made a couple of appearances since that move after 45 in 4 seasons for Millwall.

 

[shabba]

Strange selection, stange substitutions and a complete lack of man management skills, he is past his sell by date and will get us relegated.