Oasis - Yes or No?

[Shizuoka Dolphin]

Not so long ago, the general consensus seemed to be that Oasis were past it. That compared to their previous selves, they had become monotonous, repetitive, pedestrian and generally rather tiresome.

Yet their new tour had sold out within hours with an unwavering display of enthusiasm from their fans.

But what does NSC think of their recent material? Classic, timeless rock, or boring old shite?

 

[tinx]

I thought their most recent album was actually very good, not a patch on the first two but still very good.

 

[Wozza]

First two albums only. Over-rated as a live band.

 

[Northstander]

Wouldnt say my fave, but would like to see em live at least once.

AND WILL BE IN MANCHESTER STADIUM NEXT YEAR!!

 

[Juan Albion]

Not one original note and the world's most tedious vocals (Coldplay excepted).

 

[looney]

Plaigarists who cant sing or tune their guitars.

 

[D'Angelo Saxon]

Rubbish.

 

[Marshy]

The first 2 Albums were Dynamite.
Its easy to knock them after those, but in general well worth a listen.

 

[Marc]

shockingly crap live! I dont care for them at all but I do like Wonderwall as it reminds me of my first ever snowboard trip everytime I hear it, only because the French Alps radio station played it 2-3 times every f***ing HOUR so it grew on me

 

[Stumpy Tim]

Great band, great live.

Not many bands sum up the youth culture like they did

 

[looney]

Not many bands sum up the youth culture like they did

Tacky, overhyped and third rate?

 

[Stumpy Tim]

Not many bands sum up the youth culture like they did

Tacky, overhyped and third rate?

Coming out of the Thatcher years, and not really giving a shit

 

[Bigtomfu]

wheres the self opinionated manc wank option on the poll?
they can be almost as irritating as being trapped in the man utd megastore with Terry Christian on speed..

 

[Bigtomfu]

wheres the self opinionated manc wank option on the poll?
they can be almost as irritating as being trapped in the man utd megastore with Terry Christian on speed..

adendum:
great if yoou like listening to A,D, and E chords only- oh and the fact that around fifty % of their songs are clones of each other- Do you know what i meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaaannnnnnnnnnn yeah yeah!

 

[LEWES CLIFF]

The Jam of the 90s,original wonderfull songs,music that woke people up to real songs again after the shit electropop era and the "if you can dance round youre handbag to it when pissed"records that were going straight to no 1.
Maybe past it now but live superb,Knebworth,Glastonbury,anywhere ,top guns

 

[Strike]

Can't stand Oasis

 

[mejonaNO12 aka riskit]

sadly i think they are past their best now but in the 90s...wow!! legends

 

[Albion Edd]

Great band, Denfintley maybe is a superb album, Morning glory and the masterplan are also quality, I thought heathen chemistry was a decent album too. I can't wait to see them in Milton Keyenes

 

[Northstander]

Manchester stadium has sold out, they have had to add another date, hardly sounds like a crap band to me, OR if they are they are still VERY popular.

(Not sure about other venues)

 

[Juan Albion]

Manchester stadium has sold out, they have had to add another date, hardly sounds like a crap band to me, OR if they are they are still VERY popular.

(Not sure about other venues)

The Sun sells rather well too, but I still hesitate to call it a quality newspaper.