McGhee out, Sturrock in

[fatboy]

Can McGhee get enough out of what are not a bad bunch of players?

Discuss.

 

[B.M.F]

I think he can. I know it is going to take time but he is good at bringing youngsters through. Juat look at Millwall for that.

 

[Stumpy Tim]

if they are not a bunch of players, what are they?? A herd of players?

 

[Easy 10]

Its been a horrendous start, but thats all it is, a start. We could have a spell like this at any point of the season, and we probably will as well. We've lost 3 and drawn 1 of our League games (don't care about the cup). McGhee has managed at this level, he has had success at this level. As I said on another thread, there is absolutely NO WAY we could get someone else in with anything LIKE McGhee's pedigree and experience if we were looking for a replacement.

He's doing the best he can with one arm tied behind his back. Get behind him and back the fella, cos if we start dishing stick and he turns round and says "f*** this then" and walks away, then we are really in the shit. Unless you actually WANT Hinshelwood/Wilkins/Booker in charge ?

 

[Albion Dan]

No manager would be able to do anything with our current squad in this division! FACT!

 

[BensGrandad]

Our problem is that we have far too many players who could be described as 'squad players' i.e they are very similar in style and ability as each other but not enough that would walk straight into the 1st team.

 

[Albion Dan]

Where the hell is John Piercy at the moment? Surely hed be better than Hinshelwood in the middle?

 

[the right footed denilson]

and 'utility' i another

 

[the full harris]

I can appreciate McGhee has got the best squad together that he can on next NO resources, BUT he uses them in such a poor way. I truly believe that this group of players could have got more out of the first five games of the season than we have.

McGhee makes crap substitutions and then whinges about the crowd when the team are playing rubbish.

Let Sturrock be manager. He will DEFINETLY do better.

GOOD THREAD TITLE RUMBLE.
ALSO, I LIKED YOUR SHIRT TONIGHT. YOUR COMPANY ARE VERY LUCKY TO HAVE SUCH A WELL TURNED OUT EMPLOYEE.

 

[fatboy]

Where the hell is John Piercy at the moment? Surely hed be better than Hinshelwood in the middle?

He has colitis.

The shits in other words.

 

[Exiled in Exeter]

Sturrock is a very good boss and will do well for someone. But not for us as we already have a good manager.

I think McGhee is doing the best he can with the limited resources.

 

[Yorkie]

He has colitis.

The shits in other words.

Rather worse than that.

We have a lot of injuries which isn't helping but the remaining players have lost their confidence.
We were doing well until we conceded a goal and the stuffing went out of them.

I think McGhee will sort it out. Plymouth carried on doing well when Sturrock had gone so who is to say that Sturrock was the great manager he appeared to be?

 

[Blackadder]

Can McGhee get enough out of what are not a bad bunch of players?

Discuss.

Ah, another of these funny wind-up threads that everyone is going on about!

We certainly has enough chances tonight!

We need our central midfield back. Chippy and (probably won't go down well with some people) Charlie need to come back!

 

[Seagull Pete]

An "English" manager would be nice! Not one of these foreign imports!!

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

It was a miracle we went up last season and frankly undeserved lets be honest. Our football last season was at best average and in the middle of the season bloody awful.

We have 5 div 1 players in my book, Roberts, Kuipers, Cullip, Carpenter and Knight. Thats it.

We are being found out. Our side is much much weaker than 2 years ago and the division is stronger.

 

[skintboy]

spot on Easy,who else would do the job,last nights phone-in mentioned Danny Wilson but he has had money at previous clubs and Mark Mcghee outwitted him in play-off final,so thats a non starter to me!!

 

[Brighton till i die]

its so f***ing early in the season - keep the faith with MM for fucks sake.

 

[Zebedee]

We have 5 div 1 players in my book, Roberts, Kuipers, Cullip, Carpenter and Knight. Thats it.

After the last few games, I'm not sure that Cullip is up to the standard of the Championship. In fact, he looks decidedly poor at the moment. Top quality hoofer though as is Virgo etc.

 

[Josky]

I'm not sure if I support this view that it was a miracle we went up last year, therefore we should expect to get relegated this year.

We've worked hard to get into this division over the course of the season and we earned the right to get here.

Everyone is saying its so early in the season, but we're not even putting in good performances and losing, just playing awful and losing.

I don't care what anyone says, we should have won last night.

 

[Josky]

Oh yeah, not sure about Sturrock though...