Has McGhee lost the dressing room?

[Icy Gull]

Maybe those that were there can confirm or deny it, but to me it sounded like he and the team are still playing for each other, showing plenty of fight and spirit. Long may it continue, maybe it won't make up for what we lack in class, but they are proving once again the spirit that got us where we are is still there

Doesn't sound like a good idea to even contemplate sacking the manager to me. If he loses the dressing room, well that would be something different

That is all

 

[bhaexpress]

How can he lose the dressing room ? I know it's at the West end of Withdean now but it's been there for months !

 

[veade]

it makes you wonder but that wouldn't that mean the players are sticking with him in feel he will drop them like he did kuipers never to play again for having an opinion

 

[Uncle Buck]

So 5 wins this season is good enough for him to keep his job Icy?

The facts and figures suggest that he is failing miserably and if people are happy to accept it we are in a whole load of trouble both on and off the pitch.

 

[3gulls]

Maybe those that were there can confirm or deny it, but to me it sounded like he and the team are still playing for each other, showing plenty of fight and spirit. Long may it continue, maybe it won't make up for what we lack in class, but they are proving once again the spirit that got us where we are is still there

Doesn't sound like a good idea to even contemplate sacking the manager to me. If he loses the dressing room, well that would be something different

That is all

No, just the players out of it!

 

[sir danny cullip]

I think MM has lost a certain few players, particularly CKR but hes still been able to keep the main experienced players eg chippy, butters, mayo even though hes fallen out with kuipers. One thing i couldnt understand last night was taking Gary Hart off when he could have been the player to go back and mark huckerby when hinsh got tired. The second goal was a direct result of no one knowing who was supposed to be marking him after hinsh went off.

 

[Uncle Buck]

I think MM has lost a certain few players, particularly CKR but hes still been able to keep the main experienced players eg chippy, butters, mayo even though hes fallen out with kuipers. One thing i couldnt understand last night was taking Gary Hart off when he could have been the player to go back and mark huckerby when hinsh got tired. The second goal was a direct result of no one knowing who was supposed to be marking him after hinsh went off.

You reckon that he has fallen out with CKR?

 

[Icy Gull]

So 5 wins this season is good enough for him to keep his job Icy?

.

Given the circumstances he is working under, yes. I'm not happy about it and I'd rather we were in Reading's position but I'm a realist about it. I expected to be where we are but hoped we wouldn't be.

Not saying DK should get the flak, but it is the board stifling McGhee, not him being bad at his job imo. Just hope he realises there are enough people who understand the problems to stop him walking. You and many others hope exactly the opposite. though.

Still like to see what those at the game thought of last night's performance and tactics though. Anyone?

 

[sir danny cullip]

You reckon that he has fallen out with CKR?

Well I sit in B Block and CKR wasnt at all happy during theleicester game with being on the bench and then not coming on, he wasnt even warming up just laughing and joking and kicking sand. Against Burnley he was with Kuipers and you could tell kuipers was annoyed he looked very animated and him and CKR didnt look too pleased. Sounds like im clutching at straws but seriously he doesnt look interested at all. To be fair though he hasnt had much of a chance, last night he came on for harty up front and within 5 minutes hinsh was sent off and CKR was told to play right wing!

 

[Uncle Buck]

Given the circumstances he is working under, yes. I'm not happy about it and I'd rather we were in Reading's position but I'm a realist about it. I expected to be where we are but hoped we wouldn't be.

Not saying DK should get the flak, but it is the board stifling McGhee, not him being bad at his job imo. Just hope he realises there are enough people who understand the problems to stop him walking. You and many others hope exactly the opposite. though.

Still like to see what those at the game thought of last night's performance and tactics though. Anyone?

OK, 5 wins is not good enough, it is bloody awful and worryingly since November, we have generally deserved to lose the games we have lost.

Maybe the board is stifling McGhee, but maybe that is down to the fact that they do not overly trust his judgement when it comes to the transfer market and so are reluctant to give him funds?

 

[the wanderbus]

I was watching ckr juggling stones & kicking sand on saturday, he seemed like a disinterested ,petulant little kid . Its about time someone had a word about his attitude.Its not as if he's even that good , at his age he should be grabbing each & every opportunity he gets.

 

[Icy Gull]

Maybe the board is stifling McGhee, but maybe that is down to the fact that they do not overly trust his judgement when it comes to the transfer market and so are reluctant to give him funds?

No doubt we'll find out in time. In the meantime he has my backing, which means f all to anyone but me

 

[Brighton4eva]

Can we afford one of those?

 

[Lammy]

You could give McGhee £1m and he STILL wouldn't be able to get anyone to join!

Does he have ANY contacts? We haven't even been able to get any yougsters from Brady!

 

[Tony Meolas Loan Spell]

OK, 5 wins is not good enough, it is bloody awful and worryingly since November, we have generally deserved to lose the games we have lost.

This is true. At the beginning of the season it was we need to turn these draws into wins blah blah blah.

Now we cant even get draws.

 

[Uncle Buck]

This is true. At the beginning of the season it was we need to turn these draws into wins blah blah blah.

Now we cant even get draws.

But the results at the beginning of the season did not matter...

 

[The Large One]

Maybe those that were there can confirm or deny it, but to me it sounded like he and the team are still playing for each other, showing plenty of fight and spirit. Long may it continue, maybe it won't make up for what we lack in class, but they are proving once again the spirit that got us where we are is still there

Doesn't sound like a good idea to even contemplate sacking the manager to me. If he loses the dressing room, well that would be something different

That is all

He hasn't 'lost' the dressing room, and he didn't 'fall out' with Kuipers because 'he expressed an opinion'. To say he did is pure and utter fantasy bullshit. CKR and FDM may well have got the hump for not being picked, but that is their problem.

As to what I understand did happen, well, I can't say. Or rather - won't say.

 

[3gulls]

Re: Re: Has McGhee lost the dressing room?

CKR and FDM may well have got the hump for not being picked, but that is their problem.

And ours. We are even worse without them! At Coventry, Henderson got injured and Magoo could not sub him because he only had a kid on the bench. Nice!

 

[Sargey]

I really think the guy has lost it now...

This season he has tried to turn OGH & Reidy into full backs when El - Abd, Mayo & Lynch were available, Played Hinshelwood on the wing when Reidy, OGH,Robinson or Cox could of played there and permutated his front line so many times it's unreal.

I reckon we do have the players who could of kept us up but severe mis-management hasn't got the best out of those players and by playing them out of position or over rotating them has knocked their confidence and confused them as how to play where.

McGhee wqill you please stop around with the team with these totally weird selections....

I'm afraid he must go and now.....

 

[3gulls]

I really think the guy has lost it now...

This season he has tried to turn OGH & Reidy into full backs when El - Abd, Mayo & Lynch were available, Played Hinshelwood on the wing when Reidy, OGH,Robinson or Cox could of played there and permutated his front line so many times it's unreal.

I reckon we do have the players who could of kept us up but severe mis-management hasn't got the best out of those players and by playing them out of position or over rotating them has knocked their confidence and confused them as how to play where.

McGhee wqill you please stop around with the team with these totally weird selections....

I'm afraid he must go and now.....