Best player in the championship?

[Aseros]

Intrigued to know.

 

[T soprano]

Vicente

 

[Napper]

Bolasie from the performances against us.

Vydra overall

 

[algie]

Bolasie from the performances against us.

Vydra overall

Chris Wood for Millwall was better than Bolasie.

 

[One Teddy Maybank]

Vydra best player I've seen at The Amex this year.

Consistency Bridcutt must be up there........

 

[gazingdown]

I don't think there is a "best player" as such as it's position dependant. Kuszczak is a rubbish CF for example and I doubt Vicente is any good in goal or defending.

Arguably we have a few that would make a "dream" Championship XI.
Vicente is possibly the best attacking midfielder.
Kuszczak maybe best keeper
Bridcutt best defensive midfielder
Bridge best left back
Vydra/Murray (spit...) best CF ( )
XX Best wingers
XX best central defenders
etc..

 

[Simon Morgan]

Honestly think that in terms of all-round ability it has to be Vicente. Sadly, we have to accept that Zaha and Murray are up there too. Other contenders are Vydra of Watford, Whittingham of Cardiff, and Bridcutt.

 

[One Love]

Bearing in mind Zaha has recently been sold for £10m, difficult to think of anyone else going for that sort of money so has to be him.

 

[Lovecake]

I don't think there is a "best player" as such as it's position dependant. Kuszczak is a rubbish CF for example and I doubt Vicente is any good in goal or defending.

Arguably we have a few that would make a "dream" Championship XI.
Vicente is possibly the best attacking midfielder.
Kuszczak maybe best keeper
Bridcutt best defensive midfielder
Bridge best left back
Vydra/Murray (spit...) best CF ( )
XX Best wingers
XX best central defenders
etc..

You're over thinking it. Messi widely touted as the best player in the world but he's probably not great in goal is he... it's still a valid question

 

[gazingdown]

You're over thinking it. Messi widely touted as the best player in the world but he's probably not great in goal is he... it's still a valid question

Oh I know, but the "best" player in the Championship/PL/World/etc. ALWAYS seems to favour attacking midfielders or forwards. I never hear of a defender (or keeper!) being the best player.

 

[Kazenga <3]

Bearing in mind Zaha has recently been sold for £10m, difficult to think of anyone else going for that sort of money so has to be him.

That takes into account age and potential though. If Vicente was 21 he'd be worth that.

Actually bids for Vicente at that age were around £30 million.

 

[amexee]

Bearing in mind Zaha has recently been sold for £10m, difficult to think of anyone else going for that sort of money so has to be him.

You clearly have difficulty thinking. The question was not about transfer value , but best player. If you really think Zaha at this point in time could do half what Vicente is capable of, then your faculties are clearly faulty

 

[severnside gull]

I would struggle to pick a single best player - is it "on a good day" or is it about consistency over a season?

Picking a team is easier but undoubtably no less contentious
I would agree that the PiG. Bridge, Bridders and Vicente might all be in with a shout..........

 

[One Love]

That takes into account age and potential though. If Vicente was 21 he'd be worth that.

Actually bids for Vicente at that age were around £30 million.

But he's not 21 is he.

 

[One Love]

You clearly have difficulty thinking. The question was not about transfer value , but best player. If you really think Zaha at this point in time could do half what Vicente is capable of, then your faculties are clearly faulty

I have difficulty thinking!!! LMAO

Can you be included in this discussion when you've played less than 10% of the season?

 

[The Terminator]

Well the answer is Vicente, the most gifted player by far. Also I would he he impacts the game more than anyone.

Other than him I'd say Vydra, Bellemy, Whittingham, Zaha are all up there. Ill also give a mention the Chris Burke

 

[Ninja Elephant]

Vicente. Undoubted. But too few opposition fans will have noticed. Derby spotted it last season though!

 

[scooter1]

On technical ability it would be Vicente, but he can't really be considered because of the few games he's played. For me it would be Bridcutt, he was our player of the year last year having competently made the step up from Lge 1. And I think he'll be our player of the year this year. The consistency, and potentially being player of the year twice on the bounce of a team doing well, says that he could possibly be the best in the league right now

 

[brightonrock]

IMO:

GK: Schmeichel/Kuszczak
LB: Bridge/Olsson
RB: St.Ledger/Parr
CB: Hudson/Dann/Mills/Hobbs
DM: Bridcutt/Trotter
LM: Whittingham/Ince
RM: Zaha/Adomah
AM: Vicente/Vydra
ST: Rhodes/Austin/Wood/Murray

 

[amexee]

I have difficulty thinking!!! LMAO

Can you be included in this discussion when you've played less than 10% of the season?

I have not played in any of the games, but thanks for your belief in me. Please try to think before you type.