Glenn-Murray
Banned
- Jun 24, 2011
- 1,808
Depending on how well he does, "Winifred" as you call him could end up costing United well over £20m.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Zaha charged by the FA [was: could be banned]
- Thread starter Red'n'Blue
- Start date
Depending on how well he does, "Winifred" as you call him could end up costing United well over £20m.
beorhthelm
A. Virgo, Football Genius
- Jul 21, 2003
- 36,015
look, he's good there's no denying it and a class above most in this league. but will he turn into a top premier league player, just because ManU paid 10m for him? no, it means they think he has potential to, nothing more. i think they were goaded into buying him because of the interest from others, that is to say they rate him but over paid. i'm not sure he's going to suit ManU and will have a hard time getting first team games there. it'll be a test of character how he deals with that,
Zaha could be banned
You posted the Fergie has spent £15m, he hasn't. Palarse fan who can't tell the difference between 10 and 15. Funny that.
You posted the Fergie has spent £15m, he hasn't. Palarse fan who can't tell the difference between 10 and 15. Funny that.
Glenn-Murray
Banned
- Jun 24, 2011
- 1,808
Your jealousy is palpable.
The best part is that we've got Jon Williams coming through who, when he is eventually sold, will probably go for even more! All over the papers last week that City will put in an opening bid of £8m this summer
seagullsovergrimsby
#cpfctinpotclub
The add-ons are all dependent on first team appearances , England call ups , Champions League appearances etc which may bring in £5M over several years. Winifred would have to be sold for £30M+ for Man United to write an extra £5M cheque payable to CPFC. If he doesn't make it at Man United then all the add-on bonus payments are meaningless.
Glenn-Murray
Banned
- Jun 24, 2011
- 1,808
£5m over several years isn't what has been suggested. Indications have been that we'll be seeing £5m very soon after he starts playing for United.
If he doesn't make it at United I'll be very surprised. The boy has incredible talent and should go all the way.
beorhthelm
A. Virgo, Football Genius
- Jul 21, 2003
- 36,015
"indications" you are seeing are blinkered. the whole point is the buyer sweetening the deal for a lower initial payment. they often dont expect or want to pay those fees and structure them accordingly, they would hardly put in clauses that would pay soon after joining.
little al
Crystal Palace fan
If he doesn't make it at United, then we have mugged them. Win win.
Glenn-Murray
Banned
- Jun 24, 2011
- 1,808
£5m in "very achievable" addons, then further addons that aren't so easily achievable.
Unfortunately not all football transfers are as simple as you appear to be.
You mentioned nothing about further add-ons. It was your post that was unclear.
Either way, BBC, Guardian, Football 365, and almost every other source all say a maximum of £15m. But i suppose an extra £5m added on with nothing to back the fact up is nothing eh.
Glenn-Murray
Banned
- Jun 24, 2011
- 1,808
I'd rather listen to our chairmen than Football 365.
Sorry for assuming that you had done a very limited amount of research before commenting on something.
Your jealousy is palpable.
The best part is that we've got Jon Williams coming through who, when he is eventually sold, will probably go for even more! All over the papers last week that City will put in an opening bid of £8m this summer
Don't kid yourself, with FFP coming into play you will be lucky to see 10m for him. So before opening that big mouth of yours, try putting that thing you call a brain (peanut) in to gear first.
StillHateBellotti
Active member
I don't really care!
Glenn-Murray
Banned
- Jun 24, 2011
- 1,808
Why, exactly? Palace are in good shape for FFP coming in. Our owners can't wait, they think it'll be a very good thing for football and will have a minimal effect on us.
We were told that we'd get £5m for Wilfried by some of the morons on here. I notice they're a little quieter now. Dealing exclusively in attendances most of the time!
I also like that you're mocking the fact that in your opinion we'll only get £10m for him. As if you're in any position to laugh at a club that has produced two players worth a combined £20m+ in a couple of years!
seagullsovergrimsby
#cpfctinpotclub
I can't see any club paying out straight away , logically it would be over the length of the contract eg a payment triggered for 50 first team appearances , another payment for 100 first team appearances etc.
Glenn-Murray
Banned
- Jun 24, 2011
- 1,808
No idea. The only information we can really trust is what our chairmen have let on, which isn't much, but we know that they negotiated for a very long time and because there was so much interest in Wilfried, we were able to get a very good deal that suited us down to the ground.
Brian Fantana
Well-known member
Do you believe EVERYTHING your chairmen say? They're hardly going to say 'we were fleeced, don't worry about it', are they?
I should say, I'm not saying you were fleeced. Just wondering if you always believe their statements.
seagullsovergrimsby
#cpfctinpotclub
I rather take the facts from Sir Alex Ferguson who signed Winifred but all the specific details are between the two clubs.
