Would You Welcome Back Craig Noone?

[Prince Monolulu]

Talk to me about all those other headers of the ball that weren't Murray or Ulloa.

Do you have the stats handy on the headers? Ash must be in there somewhere.

 

[Dirk Lehmann's Python]

Do you have the stats handy on the headers? Ash must be in there somewhere.

I don't. He definitely got a few but if anyone is going to try and make a case that Ashley Barnes was a strong aerial presence for us then they are a liar

 

[Prince Monolulu]

I don't. He definitely got a few but if anyone is going to try and make a case that Ashley Barnes was a strong aerial presence for us then they are a liar

Might I suggest the word 'mistaken' rather than 'a liar'?

No man has a good enough memory to be a successful liar - Abraham Lincoln

 

[Dirk Lehmann's Python]

Might I suggest the word 'mistaken' rather than 'a liar'?

No man has a good enough memory to be a successful liar - Abraham Lincoln

yes, that's fair!

 

[Mellor 3 Ward 4]

I liked Noone, he was excellent the season Cardiff went up, and was decent in the PL. I'd be pleased if we got him back, thought it was a wrong move when we let him go.

Agree, although Poyet always had the policy of not standing in any players way.

 

[portslade seagull]

No thanks. I'd prefer Marshall

 

[Easy 10]

"Nice lad", good attitude, but a junk winger. Crossing was atrocious, and shooting was desperately poor (hence the 4 goals in 60). His shots ended up on more billboards than Eva Herzigova.

Plus his gushing starry-eyed ADULATION of Liverpool FC (along with Navarro) in the buildup to that FA Cup match at Anfield was frankly embarrassing. Made me feel like I was following a non-league team up there "just happy to be here, like".

No. Lets focus on getting a proper winger in, like Knockaert.

 

[BensGrandad]

Good squad player but would he be first choice, probably not.

 

[perseus]

No one on the Wing

Width of the post away for me. Wrong side of the post. Knockeart is left-footed as well.

 

[perseus]

Addnda: Noone was always better at defending than Buckley. Jamie Murphy has shown signs of tracking back and winning tackles cleanly recently. I don't think Knockeart is renowned for that. Neither is Blackman of Reading now Derby.

Not sure if the second striker should defend all that much. Diverts his focus from the job of scoring goals.

 

[Bombadier Botty]

Another vote for 'Underwhelming' here