[Albion] Would you sign Halford permanently?

[Norman Baker suck my lozenge]

Will be bitterly disappointed if any of our combination of back four play for us again,old,slow,no ariel dominance,turned inside out far to often,get rid of the lot and start from scratch.

 

[BensGrandad]

Not good enough as first choice and we dont need him and Calderon as utility defender one or the other.

 

[Ninja Elephant]

I was very opposed to his signing originally, I considered him a mercenary, someone who wouldn't care about the club or the team.

I was completely wrong, his attitude on the pitch was absolutely spot on and he gave everything for us. He is definitely someone we should be looking to keep on, he covers many positions and appears to be spot on in his approach.

 

[spence]

No not good enough

 

[Meade's Ball]

On a reasonable wage i'd think he's worth a shot. Not sure he's the titan centrehalf we need to quell any sudden pacy attacks, but he's a good allround player and with a pre-season fully knowing the role, and even forming a partnership with a more leading centreback, he'd be good enough. I'd cheer his end of game arrival from the bench if he didn't start though, looking forward to one of his throw-ins from sideline in our own half to penalty spot for some giant Danish goalmachine to flick in.

 

[London Irish]

Too slow so no - getting beaten once by Callum Wilson is acceptable, three times in a couple of seconds is not

 

[OzMike]

Yes, but only 1 day before the transfer window shuts and at bargain price, as usual.

 

[Rugrat]

If he's the sort we're after to revitalise our team then it's likely to be another sorry campaign

As a Hughes replacement, maybe

 

[Blue3]

Yes. Out of contract so no fee.

Probably not expensive wage wise.

Versatile player that would provide cover when needed and sit on the bench when not.

This is my view

 

[8ace]

81 clueless bellends

 

[Blue Valkyrie]

81 clueless bellends

In 49 posts. That's promotion level bellendary

 

[Mellotron]

81 clueless bellends

Bit harsh. He caused problems when he came on last night. I'm not exactly gutted we didn't sign him, but to call 81 people "bellends" is insanely over the top.

 

[Iamapen15]

He was installed as Club Captain of Rotherham when Evans signed him. However, after 5 or 6 games he was stripped of it, the pie eater extraordinaire doesn't think he's good enough to start, let alone captain the team!

He's performed poorly in a poor team. He's also got some personal issues. In my view our recruitment this season makes any thought of signing him seems unbelievable now.