Would We Swop Our Players For Palarse's

[Hornblower]

They seem to want to take our best players who IMO show a lot more promise than all but a handful of their current squad. But, let's be honest, they have made a couple of good signings and they do still have some half-useful players. So, if you could would you swop our squad for theirs?

My answer is a big fat NO!

 

[theboybilly]

Speroni as back-up to Kooshack instead of Ankergren? Maybe.

 

[HastingsSeagull]

Speroni as back-up to Kooshack instead of Ankergren? Maybe.

This is about the only one. Would take Murray too but as depth behind Ulloa. Swap him for Barker maybe? Williams would be bench here (generous as we loaded at CM) but has potential. Can't think of anyone else worth the wages tbh!

 

[KingstonSeagull]

*swap

 

[mejonaNO12 aka riskit]

I was hoping it was just a typo....but then I realised you spelt it 'swop' twice.

I hope you're ashamed.

 

[Couldn't Be Hyypia]

I don't want to seem negative, but isn't it time we stopped obsessing about Palace. It's no wonder their trolls come on here to stir things up.

 

[Kazenga <3]

Difficult decision personally.



Reckon ours shades it slightly as an overall squad- a lot of very mediocre Championship players in Palace's, defence particularly weak.

I think the way to do it would be to pick an 18 from both and see who has more players in that 18. I'd go for

Kuszczak

Bruno Greer Upson Moxey

Bridcutt Jedinak

Buckley Guedioura Campana

Ulloa​

Subs: Speroni, Gabbidon, Calderon, Puncheon, Orlandi, Chamakh, Williams

Make it 9 each there in a balanced 18. Would say ours maybe slightly the better of the two purely from a defensive perspective. Whereas bar Ulloa and Buckley, they certainly have the edge going forwards, including players outside that 18 as well.

 

[albionite]

Will not be long before a palace bellend links this to bbs and they all say Brighton fans are deluded, they wouldn't have one of our players in their team.
Maybe Bridcutt and Ulloa could warm their bench.

These make me laugh but we really do need an away section so these type of wind up threads don't pollute main section

 

[albionite]

Difficult decision personally.

View attachment 46734View attachment 46735

Reckon ours shades it slightly as an overall squad- a lot of very mediocre Championship players in Palace's, defence particularly weak.

I think the way to do it would be to pick an 18 from both and see who has more players in that 18. I'd go for

Kuszczak

Bruno Greer Upson Moxey

Bridcutt Jedinak

Buckley Guedioura Campana

Ulloa​

Subs: Speroni, Gabbidon, Calderon, Puncheon, Orlandi, Chamakh, Williams

Make it 9 each there in a balanced 18. Would say ours maybe slightly the better of the two purely from a defensive perspective. Whereas bar Ulloa and Buckley, they certainly have the edge going forwards, including players outside that 18 as well.

Looks reasonable to me. Debatable if Campana should get a slot over Orlandi also Lopez when he finds his form again

 

[Mellotron]

Probably not. We finished higher last season. They haven't improved their awful defence at all, and it's hard to say what's going to happen with the bizarre attacking options they've brought in.

 

[Hornblower]

I was hoping it was just a typo....but then I realised you spelt it 'swop' twice.

I hope you're ashamed.

I thought it was an either or?

 

[Hornblower]

Will not be long before a palace bellend links this to bbs and they all say Brighton fans are deluded, they wouldn't have one of our players in their team.
Maybe Bridcutt and Ulloa could warm their bench.

These make me laugh but we really do need an away section so these type of wind up threads don't pollute main section

Just a bit of fun.

 

[MJsGhost]

I'd take Puncheon in a heartbeat - I think he'll prove to be their most shrewd acquisition (albeit on a loan basis).

I'd take Chamakh too - anyone who doubts he'd be very effective in the championship hugely underestimates the gap in quality between the prem and championship in my opinion.

I'd take Williams for the DS too, but that's about it. Not necessarily because I think the rest of our squad is streets ahead, but there's no point swapping for players who aren't used to our passing style.

 

[ThePaddy]

Anyone saying they wouldn't take Joel Ward is on drugs or hasn't watched Palace play

 

[Mackenzie]

Williams might develop into something decent, as could the Spanish lad....the rest meh!

 

[Kazenga <3]

Anyone saying they wouldn't take Joel Ward is on drugs or hasn't watched Palace play

Joel Ward was shocking for Pompey against us. Remember Vicente completely doing him about 6 times in 30 minutes at the Amex.

 

[Hillian1]

They'd have to have a damn good wash first, but Williams and Puncheon.

Maybe Jedinak as cover for Bridders.

 

[ThePaddy]

Joel Ward was shocking for Pompey against us. Remember Vicente completely doing him about 6 times in 30 minutes at the Amex.

I saw in the paper yesterday he has a 100% tackle success rate in the PL this season and has made the most tackles in the league

 

[Mackenzie]

I saw in the paper yesterday he has a 100% tackle success rate in the PL this season and has made the most tackles in the league

And why do you think that might be?

 

[albionite]

I saw in the paper yesterday he has a 100% tackle success rate in the PL this season and has made the most tackles in the league

Are you seaside as well? You need to post a few more deluded posts before I make my mind up, you write like him