Worst player to don an Albion shirt?

[Guerrero]

We've all seen loads.I guess Glenn Geard who managed half a game trying to mark Liam Brady at Highbury and never played a first team game again after being totally humiliated would be my call.

 

[brightonrock]

Cue some NSC dullard naming current squad players they have grudges for...

 

[Guerrero]

That certainly wasn't the purpose.
I'm now going to add Alan Duffy as my second worst.

 

[Steve Foster]

Current squad - Holroyd
However, Richard Tiltman may have been worse (just)

 

[Guerrero]

Yes,Tiltman was very poor.Have to agree.Never more than a Conference player at best.

 

[Spider]

Is it a month since this thread last came up? Seems to have come around very quickly!

Anyway, as always, my offering is Sam Williams.

 

[Beach Hut]

Dirk Lehman or Turienso

 

[portlock seagull]

Please have mercy, not this thread again. It's been days since last posted. Can't we debate merits of capital punishment instead....zzzzzzzz

 

[acrossthepond]

Me

 

[Harry H]

Please have mercy, not this thread again. It's been days since last posted. Can't we debate merits of capital punishment instead....zzzzzzzz

OK.I'll go along with that.
Which person ever connected with the Albion deserves a painful death?

I reckon Gordon Smith.

 

[bhaexpress]

OK.I'll go along with that.
Which person ever connected with the Albion deserves a painful death?

I reckon Gordon Smith.

No, that has to be Micky 'Taff Tosser' Thomas.

 

[Icy Gull]

Icelandic Arsenal loanee Valur Gislasson. Had to be a ringer, I know we have had some dreadful loanees from Arsenal but this guy couldn't play football any better than me and you wouldn't have wanted me anywhere near an Albion team...ever.

 

[Icy Gull]

OK.I'll go along with that.
Which person ever connected with the Albion deserves a painful death?

I reckon Gordon Smith.

The guy who scored the opening goal in an FA Cup final? oh yes of course he does

So he failed to net the winner, I see worse misses from Albion strikers every game

 

[bhaexpress]

The guy who scored the opening goal in an FA Cup final? oh yes of course he does

So he failed to net the winner, I see worse misses from Albion strikers every game

He's also the big man in Scottish football who managed to get to Gary Hart's testimonial and no doubt will be here when we play our first game at Falmer. I hope Michael Robinson gets asked, not all ex Brighton players go downhill when they leave here.

 

[Jimbo26]

Mike Ferguson

 

[Hercules Rockerfeller]

Glen Thomas. Scored one and set one up on his debut, but unfortunately they were both for Brentford, who we were playing.

 

[Jesus Gul]

Ashley Neal

 

[Deano's Invisible Pants]

Grant Horscraft would take some beating. Did well for Lewes though!

 

[Deportivo Seagull]

Grant Horscraft would take some beating. Did well for Lewes though!

Mahoney-johnson

thread closed!

 

[Billy the Fish]

We've all seen loads.I guess Glenn Geard who managed half a game trying to mark Liam Brady at Highbury and never played a first team game again after being totally humiliated would be my call.

Been done a million times before fella, but as you're new...


Always the same answer from me, a toss up between Ashley Neale or Damien Hilton