- Aug 8, 2005
- 27,246
- Thread starter
- #81
Our set up is a million times better than Wigan. No comparison.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Win the FA Cup or stay up this season?
- Thread starter Giraffe
- Start date
Our set up is a million times better than Wigan. No comparison.
Unfortunately, there are TWO other options!
hart's shirt
Well-known member
Staying up would mean that Albion supporters living overseas could watch them play every game.
It's been a huge privilege and joy this season for us, regardless of the individual match result.
But that's a small sacrifice to pay for the glory of Albion winning a major trophy.
Cup it is.
It's been a huge privilege and joy this season for us, regardless of the individual match result.
But that's a small sacrifice to pay for the glory of Albion winning a major trophy.
Cup it is.
FA Cup win for me.
I would like us to actually win something other than the two lower leagues, and the Charity Sheild before any of us were born.
Last season was a massive achievement and very enjoyable, but the icing on the cake would have been actually winning the Championship obviously.
Staying in the PL makes sense, but will the novelty wear off being in a relegation battle every season?
I'm pretty sure if we went down it wouldn't take us long to get promoted again.
By the way, we are not Wigan Athletic
Egg chasing is more important in that town.
I would like us to actually win something other than the two lower leagues, and the Charity Sheild before any of us were born.
Last season was a massive achievement and very enjoyable, but the icing on the cake would have been actually winning the Championship obviously.
Staying in the PL makes sense, but will the novelty wear off being in a relegation battle every season?
I'm pretty sure if we went down it wouldn't take us long to get promoted again.
By the way, we are not Wigan Athletic
Egg chasing is more important in that town.
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
It's really not either-or.
I go for the rebel option of both.
In truth we just need to concentrate on beating both Coventry and Swansea for now, and see where that leads us.
I go for the rebel option of both.
In truth we just need to concentrate on beating both Coventry and Swansea for now, and see where that leads us.
Agree. Both.
(cough)... but isn’t that a cop out from the question?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Uh_huh_him
Well-known member
- Sep 28, 2011
- 12,153
Cup.
The emotions of promotion to the Premier league were incredible.
A day never to be forgotten and a season to be savoured.
But.....
Does anyone really think finishing 17th and winning 1 more season in the Prem, would be more satisfying than winning the world famous FA cup??
Seriously??
The emotions of promotion to the Premier league were incredible.
A day never to be forgotten and a season to be savoured.
But.....
Does anyone really think finishing 17th and winning 1 more season in the Prem, would be more satisfying than winning the world famous FA cup??
Seriously??
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
Yes, in a way, but it's a question with further alternative answers.
Bold Seagull
strong and stable with me, or...
Might not be 1 more season though, cling on here and we could establish a prolonged period in the top flight, start churning out stars from the Academy, enjoy expanding support, stronger squads, who knows, compete for a Europa League spot, future cup runs. We'll have even more chances of winning the FA cup in the future.
This season won't be our only chance for the cup, but get relegated and it could be for a long time...
You can tell who hasn't underwritten the club to the tune of about £30m a year.
LowKarate
New member
Stay up.
Continue to strengthen the team.
Establish in the Premier League.
Sooner or later we would have an even better chance to win the cup.
Have patience. We don't need to do everything in one year.
Continue to strengthen the team.
Establish in the Premier League.
Sooner or later we would have an even better chance to win the cup.
Have patience. We don't need to do everything in one year.
Frankie
Put him in the curry
Win FA Cup value over all rounds = 2.7 million ish then probable 1.8 for Europa cup visit
Stay up value = 128 million ish
It's a toughy .
Stay up value = 128 million ish
It's a toughy .
Stay up.
HastingsSeagull
Well-known member
Voted win the cup although know the sensible choice is to stay up and build.
Making the final and not winning really wouldn't mean anything in the modern age but winning it all does. I'm also assuming while we'd have a chance to win it again if we chose to stay up, it would still be an outside shot! Even if we go down I think we'll doing things the right way and would bounce back within a year or two.
Making the final and not winning really wouldn't mean anything in the modern age but winning it all does. I'm also assuming while we'd have a chance to win it again if we chose to stay up, it would still be an outside shot! Even if we go down I think we'll doing things the right way and would bounce back within a year or two.
Bold Seagull
strong and stable with me, or...
I know, we're all pretty good with the romance, sitting in our 'own' seat no matter what the cost. But don't spend £50m in a transfer window and its pitch forks and burning torches!
Falmer Flutter ©
Well-known member
Cup, Cup and then Cup again. You have to take those chances to, you know, actually win something if they come around.
Yes it did, they now a major trophy on their domestic honours list. Unlike us, or the Nigels for that matter.
And imagine winning a trophy before them! An additional bonus.
As for Wigan, they will probably go up this year and into the top division once again some day in the not too distant future. Football doesn't begin and end in the Premier League.