Williams V Barlow

[Uncle Spielberg]

Who is the champion of the ex boy band fight between Robbie " attention seeker, poor me with my £ 80 000 000 and shagging Kylie and Nicole I have to smoke 60 cigs a day and drink 40 cups of coffee and 20 red bulls as life is so tough for me, Williams " and Gary " I am a fat bastard and proud of it " Barlow.

For me Barlow was ALWAYS the talented one in Take That and Williams is a pale imitation who has made a couple of decent songs and made a damn good living from it for 10 years now. Barlow did a decent couple of solo songs but was dumped and then tried to eat 2000 cream cakes in a day and went AWOL.

What a glorious return for Barlow with the superb Patience, something head and shoulders better than Williams could come close to recordiing.

Its fat bastard Barlow for me all the way.

 

[turienzo's lovechild]

barlow


by about a MILLION miles

better voice, can play an instrument, writes great songs

 

[Trigger]

Obviously the answer is... GARY.

 

[tedebear]

Just thinking about Williams in those horrible little tiger undercrackers makes my skin crawl...besides the musical aspect...Barlow all the way...

 

[rospants]

gary barlow, he is far more talented that robbie, who is now a bitter has-been. Although i did like angels

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

"She's the one" and "Angels" amongst a few others are classics, but i think Barlow has this won

 

[bigc]

I think Robbie dug his own grave with that arrogant and self loving clip he did after he got that new contract a few years back "i'm rich, etc etc"

 

[Big Jim]

I think Robbie was a pr@t when he dumped his song writer (the one who wrote the classics, although he claims to have co-wrote them).
Up his own @rse too much.

Barlow at least comes across as human. so Barlow wins