Should be, but won’t.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Football] Will Lewis Dunk ever play for England again?
- Thread starter pasty
- Start date
Should be, but won’t.
portlock seagull
Well-known member
- Jul 28, 2003
- 17,776
Not until we change our name to Brighton & Leeds United
Baldseagull
Well-known member
Perhaps the omission of Dunk and Grealish is due to both players being crucial to their clubs, and those clubs at risk of relegation if they were to lose those players through injury, and he doesn't want to see that happen to his former club Villa, or the major club of the county he grew up in. Maybe Kalvin Philips is in because he doesn't give a shit about Leeds, or he has bought into the Bielsamessiah myth and thinks they won't be anywhere near trouble this season?
- Nov 11, 2009
- 12,267
EPL - English Premier Leeds. Top 4 go into the Champions Leeds
Tokyohands
Well-known member
Well I don't want to share him 
- Nov 11, 2009
- 12,267
- Nov 11, 2009
- 12,267
Interesting alternative England squad on talkshite thats based on opta stats alone, a lot of Southgates pets dont make it, nor unfortunately does Dunk.
But.......... Big Dan Burn is IN
https://talksport.com/football/750507/tottenham-chelsea-liverpool-and-everton-england-squad-stats/
But.......... Big Dan Burn is IN
https://talksport.com/football/750507/tottenham-chelsea-liverpool-and-everton-england-squad-stats/
Stato
Well-known member
- Dec 21, 2011
- 7,365
I have been wondering why Southgate did not explain why he has chosen not to call up a replacement after he made himself look stupid over Maguire. I found this https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-s...gue-squad-after-trial-in-greece-idUKKBN25L1M0 that states that England decided not to, but no explanation as the reasoning. No journalist seems to have asked the question.
So Dunk, Tarkowski, Coady, Lascelles, O'Connell, or whoever else is next in line are sent the message, not only would Southgate rather have a disgraced, still in court, Maguire more than you, he'd also prefer to have the proven failures Keane and Mings (and probably Stones too). He'd also prefer to have no specialist option at centre back and to instead force a terminally declining Eric Dyer, right back Kyle Walker (if he's not playing left back), or untried Championship defensive midfielder Kalvin Phillips out of position instead of you.
His explanation for leaving out Grealish was laughable. By all means pick Greenwood if you want to start with him. What is wrong with having an option like Grealish from the bench? If a few of the incompetent company man's pet players get injured before the Euros next summer, he'll be left with replacements who have little or no experience of the international set up. He is a fool and the media are not holding him to account over his favouring of players because they have come through the youth level international teams.
So Dunk, Tarkowski, Coady, Lascelles, O'Connell, or whoever else is next in line are sent the message, not only would Southgate rather have a disgraced, still in court, Maguire more than you, he'd also prefer to have the proven failures Keane and Mings (and probably Stones too). He'd also prefer to have no specialist option at centre back and to instead force a terminally declining Eric Dyer, right back Kyle Walker (if he's not playing left back), or untried Championship defensive midfielder Kalvin Phillips out of position instead of you.
His explanation for leaving out Grealish was laughable. By all means pick Greenwood if you want to start with him. What is wrong with having an option like Grealish from the bench? If a few of the incompetent company man's pet players get injured before the Euros next summer, he'll be left with replacements who have little or no experience of the international set up. He is a fool and the media are not holding him to account over his favouring of players because they have come through the youth level international teams.
Well said. I used to have a great deal of respect for Southgate, but it's definitely taken a knock in the past week. How on earth are Dyer, Keane, Mings, Walker and Phillips in that squad? Last year Southgate said he wasn't picking Grealish because he didn't have enough Premier League experience. Now he picks Calvin Phillips!! As you say, why risk picking Maguire then having to drop him - and then not picking a replacement!! Bizarre. And how come Sterling was so quickly given the cold shoulder after a minor spat with Gomez, but Maguire - facing some VERY serious criminal charges - was given the all clear (at least temporarily)? It looks like Southgate is making it up as he goes along.
Stato
Well-known member
- Dec 21, 2011
- 7,365
Not forgetting that Dier has also gone straight back into the squad at the first opportunity after he climbed into the crowd to fight with a fan. An action that, whatever the reason, had it happened the other way around would have seen the fan under a very lengthy football banning order. Yet he still had the arrogance to be shocked that he got a paltry four game suspension from the FA.
Great point..
It’s sad, I do respect Southgate for bringing in the young players and his game psychology was great at the World Cup. But he’s turned into having the same failings as previous bad England managers. Utter favouritism, and not rewarding places based on form and merit.
I’m no Villa fan. But if I’m Jack Grealish watching Phillips get called up. 0 minutes in the PL I’d be fuming.
Dunk and Tarkowski likewise, convict Harry, and violence charged Dier get in ahead. And even then the other CB’s are wholly, wholly weaker in ability and form.
Mings and Keane. No manager would swap Dunk for either of those. Nor Ben White either.
So piss off Southgate. Maybe there’s just a shelf life for England managers.
Garry Nelson's Left Foot
Well-known member
Smith and Ancelotti might wish they could!
saafend_seagull
Well-known member
Dunk also assisted 3, scored 3. Coady 0.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I don’t think he’s as good as Dunk but don’t begrudge Coady a call up at all, I think he deserves it.
It’s still just absolutely ridiculous that Keane and Mings get called up ahead of Dunk though.
It’s still just absolutely ridiculous that Keane and Mings get called up ahead of Dunk though.
Djmiles
Barndoor Holroyd
Let’s face it, he will never play for England again. Time to move on unfortunately.
This is where I’m at.
Until Southgate leaves, Lewis will never play for England.
The part that especially bothers me though, is that you pretty much 100% know if Lewis had gone to Chelsea/Spurs/Arsenal he’d be in the squad now.
AmexRuislip
Retired Spy 🕵️♂️
No call up this time for Albions captain.
Southgate, you're fvcking mad
Southgate, you're fvcking mad
Wardy's twin
Well-known member
- Oct 21, 2014
- 8,866
It would be great for Lewis I know but he can say he has played for England and we really can't afford for him to go and get injured....