Who's the biggest sicknote?

[GingerBeerMan]

Between the 5 in the poll, who is most injury prone? Hoskins + Vicente don't count because they would win too easily.

 

[Husty]

Hoskins? CMS? Vincentelot?

Missing out some very obvious candidates here.

 

[PILTDOWN MAN]

Anderton or at least our version.

 

[GingerBeerMan]

Hoskins? CMS? Vincentelot?

Missing out some very obvious candidates here.

Forgot Hoskins. CMS isn't very injury prone IMO, just had one long injury. I considered Vicente but thought he'd win by a landslide so left him out. TBH I think Hoskins will win with a landslide too, I'd like to know out of these 5 which is worst because they all seem pretty even to me.

 

[shaunslats]

Hoskins shirley

 

[BUTTERBALL]

Buckley's hamstring, the weakest in football. Darren Anderton replica.

 

[Thunder Bolt]

Agustien. The others have had diagnosed injuries. Has Kemy played a full 90 mins for us yet?

 

[nomoremithras4me]

Buckley is giving the physio's more over time than Vicente at the moment

 

[Acker79]

Agustien. The others have had diagnosed injuries. Has Kemy played a full 90 mins for us yet?

136 v newport followed by 97 v Derby. (incl injury time).

 

[sparkie]

Hoskins by a mile.

 

[Surf's Up]

Anderton or at least our version.

Indeed, similar kind of player, similar sickness record.

 

[Dick Knights Mumm]

Calling Hoskins a sicknote seems particularly unkind. He looks to be a bloke that is desperate to play for our club. He simply has a bad injury. A malingerer he is not.

 

[scooter1]

Calling Hoskins a sicknote seems particularly unkind. He looks to be a bloke that is desperate to play for our club. He simply has a bad injury. A malingerer he is not.

This.
We've yet to see a fully fit Hoskins as he's rushed himself back when he shouldn't have. Hernia, not a sick note injury. Broken bone, not a sick note injury. Ruptured knee ligaments(and failed surgery), again not sick note
For me, sadly it's Buckley, he obviously has a weak hamstring with a problem that needs a proper diagnosis and a long term solution

 

[The Antikythera Mechanism]

None of those are sick notes, the only player to qualify for that honour in recent times is Vicente.

 

[Norman Potting]

Calling Hoskins a sicknote seems particularly unkind. He looks to be a bloke that is desperate to play for our club. He simply has a bad injury. A malingerer he is not.

I get he impression from his occasional Tweets that he is thoroughly p****d of with not being able to play and agree that "sicknote" is unkind. Surely if you are lucky enough to have the skills and the breaks to be doing something that many would envy you would rather be doing it that than not?

 

[Napper]

Voted Orlandi due to his career history

 

[Thunder Bolt]

Is a sicknote someone with a genuine injury, or someone who doesn't play because they can't be bothered to get fit for selection?
What is Augustien's injury?

 

[sparkie]

Calling Hoskins a sicknote seems particularly unkind. He looks to be a bloke that is desperate to play for our club. He simply has a bad injury. A malingerer he is not.

And yet the one time he was fit and able to give something back for his transfer fee and wages, he went off and left for a loan at Sheffield United.

 

[Thunder Bolt]

And yet the one time he was fit and able to give something back for his transfer fee and wages, he went off and left for a loan at Sheffield United.

His little girl died and he wanted to be near his family in Nottingham.

 

[Uncle C]

I think this thread shows off the more disgusting side of some of our supporters. Well done to those that defend our players.