Whingy to Charlton?

[Nappy thrower]

You do post alot of shit Gav.Can you calm down with your post count please.Every thread you have to post on.

 

[y2dave]

Be amazed if we get a fee for Whing considering the circumstances. In fact we will be lucky if a club like Charlton come in for him as they could probably match his contract here meaning we avoid having to settle.

 

[deletebeepbeepbeep]

But charlton are utterly skint which is why they are after him.

 

[Gav1901]

You do post alot of shit Gav.Can you calm down with your post count please.Every thread you have to post on.

Says the one who thinks Poke and Walker are no good for us :facepalm

I can post on what ever i like

 

[Cowfold Seagull]

I would think that we would let him go on a free and would never expect to get £50k for him even when he came to us and was quite good. Think that may be a typing error and that you put the 0 in by mistake.

Think the whole 50 was a typing error, not just the 0!.

Who on earth would want to pay money for Whingy?. Committed yes, reliable yes, loyal yes, but when it comes to natural footballing ability he was completely overshadowed by Calde last season. El-Abd and even Steve Cook would make better choices at right back now.

But maybe all that is in our favour, shows how much we have moved on as a club.

However, if Charlton DO want to give us money ... thank you very much! lol.

 

[B.W.]

BG's disrespect for Whingy is a disgrace, but... he will be allowed to leave for a free... I maintain he is a better player than Hoyt, who Gus consistently played despite him offering nothing but pace for game after game... BG (the 'scout') seems to think Hoyt is a better player, to me that shows zero appreciation of the game...

Let's put it like this, I don't think Charlton would show ANY interest in Hoyt...

 

[seagullsovergrimsby]

Charlton can't afford to pay out a fee for Whingy so if he goes it will be on a free.

 

[Iamapen15]

I did post about Whingy on another thread at the beginning of the week. The gist was; He is available for free however the interest from Charlton has since cooled. He wants to move back to his Brum roots.

 

[Simon Morgan]

Hope it works out for Whingy. Great pro

 

[seagullsovergrimsby]

I did post about Whingy on another thread at the beginning of the week. The gist was; He is available for free however the interest from Charlton has since cooled. He wants to move back to his Brum roots.

That only gives him 3 league options , Walsall , Chesterfield or Port Vale. If he drops into non league , Mansfield. All within a reasonble driving distance from Brum.

 

[BensGrandad]

BG's disrespect for Whingy is a disgrace, but... he will be allowed to leave for a free... I maintain he is a better player than Hoyt, who Gus consistently played despite him offering nothing but pace for game after game... BG (the 'scout') seems to think Hoyt is a better player, to me that shows zero appreciation of the game...

Let's put it like this, I don't think Charlton would show ANY interest in Hoyt...

I think that Hoyte is a far better full back than Whing in every aspect except perhaps endeavour. He is faster, more skilful, younger and was a great improvement when he arrived here from Arsenal. Having said that Calderon is better still. It would appear that Gus and his backroom staff agree.

When Whing arrived he was reasonable but sadly has gone down hill very fast and is now probably only of Div 2 standard if even that. Perhaps joining a new club will revitalise him and get him playing again.

 

[folkestonesgull]

I have a feeling that Hoyte will end up playing at a higher level than Whing...he has the physical attributes to be a good player and mainly needs to improve his positioning and concentration.

 

[MikeySmall]

I think that Hoyte is a far better full back than Whing in every aspect except perhaps endeavour. He is faster, more skilful, younger and was a great improvement when he arrived here from Arsenal. Having said that Calderon is better still. It would appear that Gus and his backroom staff agree.

When Whing arrived he was reasonable but sadly has gone down hill very fast and is now probably only of Div 2 standard if even that. Perhaps joining a new club will revitalise him and get him playing again.

For once I agree with everything you are saying!!

 

[B.W.]

I think that Hoyte is a far better full back than Whing in every aspect except perhaps endeavour. He is faster, more skilful, younger and was a great improvement when he arrived here from Arsenal. Having said that Calderon is better still. It would appear that Gus and his backroom staff agree.

When Whing arrived he was reasonable but sadly has gone down hill very fast and is now probably only of Div 2 standard if even that. Perhaps joining a new club will revitalise him and get him playing again.

Hi BG... I KNOW Gus and his staff agree with you, but on this one I don't... Hoyt had pace, no positional sense, zero distribution, no tackling ability... in fact, very little that a FB needs... he was awful in all games bar 1 or 2 near the end of his 'reign' as our RB... Gus has already said he will not renew his interest in Hoyt, which I believe also says a lot about just how much he an his staff rate him...

 

[B.W.]

I have a feeling that Hoyte will end up playing at a higher level than Whing...he has the physical attributes to be a good player and mainly needs to improve his positioning and concentration.

... which is ZERO use to us last season or now...

BTW Whing played in the Championship, and I will be surprised if Hoyte gets any higher than that...

 

[BensGrandad]

Didnt Hoyte play in tThe Championship with Watford before coming to us on loan? I think that the reason Gus hasnt gone after Hoyte is because we have Calderon who is better and also Hoyte would probably not come to us again if he thought that he was going to be a squad player. He woiuld be better off staying at Arsenal if he is not going to play regularly.

 

[B.W.]

Didnt Hoyte play in tThe Championship with Watford before coming to us on loan? I think that the reason Gus hasnt gone after Hoyte is because we have Calderon who is better and also Hoyte would probably not come to us again if he thought that he was going to be a squad player. He woiuld be better off staying at Arsenal if he is not going to play regularly.

Think that was his brother; a MUCH better player BTW...
WE aren't interested in Hoyte...

 

[Fourteenth Eye]

A telling sign is that in the photos from behind on the photo shoot gallery he is the only one who doesnt have his name on his shirt.

i love andy whing tho and still think that he has something to offer.

If he does go, he goes with our best wishes.

top player, top bloke

 

[BensGrandad]

Think that was his brother; a MUCH better player BTW...
WE aren't interested in Hoyte...

Gavin Hoyter played from Dec 2008 to end of season for Watford in the Championship 10 games.

He has been at Arsenal since he was 9yrs old and played for England U17s (2)

England U18s (14) U20s (1) Played 1 Premiership game for Arsenal and 3 League Cup.

The highest Whing has played is The Championship for Coventry never an International. A good old pro but never as good as Hoyte.

 

[Gus Poyet's inner FLAIR]

I think that Hoyte is a far better full back than Whing in every aspect except perhaps endeavour. He is faster, more skilful, younger and was a great improvement when he arrived here from Arsenal. Having said that Calderon is better still. It would appear that Gus and his backroom staff agree.

When Whing arrived he was reasonable but sadly has gone down hill very fast and is now probably only of Div 2 standard if even that. Perhaps joining a new club will revitalise him and get him playing again.

You are ALMOST correct with what you type.
Except for him being REASONABLE when he first arrived - he was actually pretty good. Didn't you even offer to drive DICK to Coventry to sign him?
Also he's not really gone downhill very fast, it's just that Claderon has SPOILT us. A little bit like when the Ambassador has a reception and gets the Ferrero Rocher out.

But yeah, Gus doesn't fancy him, that's good enough for me.