Exactly, he was player of the season but for a 16th place side, you don't have many to choose from.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Whing stalling - anyone know why?
- Thread starter Dancin Ninja BHA
- Start date
Exactly, he was player of the season but for a 16th place side, you don't have many to choose from.
Austrian Gull
Well-known member
Give the bloke a chance to make his mind up before writing his obituary.
He's got every right to look at any other offers and would be foolish just to sign a contract from Brighton without weíghing up the alternatives.
He's gone from player of the year and all-round hero to disloyal, ex-player in some people's eyes.
He's got every right to look at any other offers and would be foolish just to sign a contract from Brighton without weíghing up the alternatives.
He's gone from player of the year and all-round hero to disloyal, ex-player in some people's eyes.
There is no loyalty in football, end of.
Clubs cut players if they are surplus or shift them on if they get a good offer.
Players move for the highest wages/best contract because this is their living.
All of which are understandable.
So why do fans get such a bee in their bonnet about the "loyalty" issue. It simply doesn't, and shouldn't, exist.
Andy Whing has been great for the Albion. We didn't lock him down before the contract expired (hedging our bets maybe?) and now he can look around. Good for him. Shame if he goes but he is perfectly entitled to. I'm glad we had his total commitment whilst he was at the club, which we did, and don't expect some sort of misplaced 'loyalty' now his contract is up.
Clubs cut players if they are surplus or shift them on if they get a good offer.
Players move for the highest wages/best contract because this is their living.
All of which are understandable.
So why do fans get such a bee in their bonnet about the "loyalty" issue. It simply doesn't, and shouldn't, exist.
Andy Whing has been great for the Albion. We didn't lock him down before the contract expired (hedging our bets maybe?) and now he can look around. Good for him. Shame if he goes but he is perfectly entitled to. I'm glad we had his total commitment whilst he was at the club, which we did, and don't expect some sort of misplaced 'loyalty' now his contract is up.
The Large One
Who's Next?
Is he actually back from holiday yet?
BeardyChops
Active member
- Jan 24, 2009
- 462
Isn't he too busy trying to fix Hungry Joe's car to worry about such things as contracts?
Dick Knights Mumm
Take me Home Falmer Road
TWOCHOICEStom
Well-known member
Am I all alone here in thinking his genuinely a fantastic player??
Fourteenth Eye
Face for Radio
And therein lies the answer !! thread closed
Am I all alone here in thinking his genuinely a fantastic player??
No, you're not, he was my choice as player of the year and would hate to see him leave.
Storer68
New member
best talk to his agent - they do all the negotiations now, not the player
Bwian
Kiss my (_!_)
- Jul 14, 2003
- 15,898
Don't get me wrong, I'd prefer him to stay but if he wants to leave he's replaceable.
I'll be so glad when Falmer opens so we can become the club players want to come to for reasons other than resurrecting their careers or rescuing them from the stiffs and third or fourth choice at another club.
Worthai Seagull
Wenners
Am I all alone here in thinking his genuinely a fantastic player??
Think you are!! Ive always regarded him, at best, as being ok .
Johnny Crumplin Football
New member
Got to agree with the majority of posters on here, he was an ever present last year, performed ok, don't think he was particularilily amazing just did his job, and out shone 10 other very average players on the pitch. Thought McNulty was the classiest player to pull on the shirt last season.