Mr Putdown
Well-known member
Because when the football league was founded, it was based entirely in the north and midlands, and clubs in the south were in a different league system. It wasn't possible to win one set of leagues, and join/get promoted to the other. So the Charity Shield was a competition between the winners of the two separate systems (it wasn't related to the FA cup back then). The winners of the Southern League (us), beat the winners of the Football League (Villa), so we were the champions of the two league systems.
Thanks for that.
Out of interest, weren’t Arsenal, Chelsea, Orient, Fulham and Spurs all playing in the Football League in 1910?