You honestly think Cullip was a talented footballer then? All I remember is a forceful and effective league 1 and 2 player, who played a decent role in our championships and should be remembered as such. But in the championship, I think he looked off the pace. My point was not that he was totally useless, clearly he wasn't, he was just NOWHERE even close to how good most albion fans would have claimed when he played for us. For leadership, I think we are crying out for someone like him right now, but for talent at least two of the current defenders piss all over him, and numerous others over the last few years.
You could have the two 'classiest' defenders on the planet, and still get dicked if you weren't up for the fight. You talk about 'talented' as though tackling and winning headers are not important 'talents'.