Quick poll ahead of the MotD analysis.
What do you think it was?
What do you think it was?
[Albion] What was the appropriate punishment for the Propper challenge?
- Thread starter Bozza
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Weststander
Well-known member
75 metres away in NE corner, so honestly couldn't see it to judge.
AmexRuislip
Retired Spy 🕵️♂️
Yellow card, no intention to harm the player.
LowKarate
New member
He should be forced to watch The Generation Game with Mel and Sue.
No further punishment would then be needed.
No further punishment would then be needed.
junior
Well-known member
Straight red for me. Studs up. If that was any player from any other team, we'd all be saying red card all day long.
Sussexscots
3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3 3, 3, 3, 3 ,3 ,3 3 coach chuggers
Looked like an innocuous foil from the East Upper. My pal in the West said it was arguably a booking but the Huddersfield player went down like a spavined horse.
Hillian1
( . ) ( . )
Straight red.
Washie
Well-known member
You sick ****
Intention to harm a player is irrelevant in this case. Agree it's accidental, but studs were too high. Tight call, but judged by the letter of the law. Brave decision from the ref.
Hillian1
( . ) ( . )
Can’t see us winning any appeal when they watch that.
brighton terra
Well-known member
From the back of the Upper West Stand it looked like a pretty innocuous 50:50 challenge.
sjamesb3466
Well-known member
Agree. Not a red for me but in the modern game it's borderline therefore the FA will back the ref
LamieRobertson
Not awoke
Having seen that not a red...both players sliding in....as most players were all match....but don't bother appealing you won't get it
m20gull
Well-known member
Keep changing my mind. Thought it was red during the game but not convinced watching the highlights after the game. This clip shows why it is red - dangerous play.
Thought it was red when I saw it live and having seen MOTD, even more convinced. We'd be spitting mad if a player did that against us,
I do agree with Danny Murphy though when he says there are too many reds in the modern game - that probably wouldn't have been a foul 40 years ago. But in today's environment, straight red.
I do agree with Danny Murphy though when he says there are too many reds in the modern game - that probably wouldn't have been a foul 40 years ago. But in today's environment, straight red.