What a waste of money

[sir albion]

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/teams/n/newcastle_united/6927869.stm




Useless and will be crap there

 

[hans kraay fan club]

Average, and will not even get a game up front. Will be fifth in teh pecking order behind Owen, martins, Viduka and probably even Ameobi.

 

[Trigger]

Couldn't agree more, still at least you wont see much of him of the pitch barring injuries, Martins, Owen and Viduka are all better than him by a mile, he's GASH.

 

[Trigger]

Average, and will not even get a game up front. Will be fifth in teh pecking order behind Owen, martins, Viduka and probably even Ameobi.

Don't forget Carroll too, he looks a pretty decent striker prospect, and the young 15 year old Dutch kid they gave a game to last night, I reckon he's better than Smith too.

 

[questier]

I thought smith looked quality when he came back from his injury. Especially when Utd played Watford in the F.A cup

 

[hans kraay fan club]

I thought smith looked quality when he came back from his injury. Especially when Utd played Watford in the F.A cup

 

[Billy the Fish]

The fact that fergie didn't want Smith to go would suggest he isn't crap. I'd think that he will be in competition with Viduka as a target man, and Martins or Owen going for the pacy striker position.

 

[hans kraay fan club]

The fact that fergie didn't want Smith to go would suggest he isn't crap. I'd think that he will be in competition with Viduka as a target man, and Martins or Owen going for the pacy striker position.

Respectfully, bollocks.

If Fergie wanted him to stay he'd offer him a new deal, and tell him he was in his plans. He's done neither so its off to sunny Newcastle for Alan.

 

[gjh1971]

Also remember he scored over 120 goals for Arsenal

 

[Trigger]

Also remember he scored over 120 goals for Arsenal

6 million quid for a 44 year old is taking the piss.

 

[severnside gull]

attacking midfield just behind the front men which is what ferguson was grooming him for
he will prove a good buy

 

[Billy the Fish]

Respectfully, bollocks.

If Fergie wanted him to stay he'd offer him a new deal, and tell him he was in his plans. He's done neither so its off to sunny Newcastle for Alan.

Mabye, but they weren't actively looking to sell, they just couldn't guarentee him first team football so he wanted to leave. It's a situation of not good enough to keep at all costs but good enough to keep as a squad player. It still doesn't make him shit

 

[scooter1]

Mabye, but they weren't actively looking to sell, they just couldn't guarentee him first team football so he wanted to leave. It's a situation of not good enough to keep at all costs but good enough to keep as a squad player. It still doesn't make him shit

Is that right, Smith said to the press that Fergie hadn't spoken to him for ages and he didn't know where he stood - which was why he was considering his options... As for going to Newcastle, silly move. If he really wants to play week in, week out he should go to bloody Derby or Wigan, a team where he'll be higher up the pecking order

 

[Billy the Fish]

Is that right, Smith said to the press that Fergie hadn't spoken to him for ages and he didn't know where he stood - which was why he was considering his options... As for going to Newcastle, silly move. If he really wants to play week in, week out he should go to bloody Derby or Wigan, a team where he'll be higher up the pecking order

That's what they were implying on talksport the other day, so as HKFC says it could well be utter bollocks