Did Sanchez do any post match press last night ?
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] VAR decision on Estupiñán goal
- Thread starter singing4seagulls
- Start date
No. RdeZ did. Didn’t you see him?
At the time, I was so upset with that goal being overturned by VAR at Selhurst. The initial celebration was unreal. I reasoned with myself that VAR must be right on this one and that I just needed to suck it up.
If I’d known then what I know now, I’d have walked out, I’d have been inconsolable. I stopped watching F1 because the ineptitude of the officials was affecting World Championships. I’m seriously close to binning off football too. I’m sick of it.
The hopes and dreams of all of us Brighton fans, investing so much time, money and most importantly, emotion and loyalty into following the team, only for some twonk on VAR missing the last Palace defender and taking a critical goal away from us.
I don’t know when I’ll have the confidence to celebrate a goal again knowing that VAR can’t be trusted on any level.
If I’d known then what I know now, I’d have walked out, I’d have been inconsolable. I stopped watching F1 because the ineptitude of the officials was affecting World Championships. I’m seriously close to binning off football too. I’m sick of it.
The hopes and dreams of all of us Brighton fans, investing so much time, money and most importantly, emotion and loyalty into following the team, only for some twonk on VAR missing the last Palace defender and taking a critical goal away from us.
I don’t know when I’ll have the confidence to celebrate a goal again knowing that VAR can’t be trusted on any level.
One other thing on this was the length of time it took to rule the goal out. They actually took an age to draw the wrong line! I'd have a modicum more sympathy if they had 20 seconds to come to a decision (which I believe is the maximum amount of time any decision should take) but it took probably 2 mins to make this glaring error with not one of the people involved saying, "oi, you've drawn the line from the wrong player". Very fishy.
Yes. But I don’t see that RDZ did much wrong. Sanchez definitely did, MacAllister also fairly culpable.
Kind of irrelevant anyway because the referee would just say I trust the team, they made the decision for me and it looks like a mistake. Net result is the same all round
Garry Nelson's Left Foot
Well-known member
Misread a post. ignore!
Bold Seagull
strong and stable with me, or...
The technology is very limited - there has been no allowance for this.
They’re using the technology as if there is no margin or error in it - take the Harvey Barnes goal yesterday, a frame before he’s onside.
It just isn’t that accurate - the decision on which frame the ball has left the passing player, where the line is drawn from, thickness of the lines, detail of the still image.
Something needs to be done as you cannot use a fallible system as if it is infallible.
They’re using the technology as if there is no margin or error in it - take the Harvey Barnes goal yesterday, a frame before he’s onside.
It just isn’t that accurate - the decision on which frame the ball has left the passing player, where the line is drawn from, thickness of the lines, detail of the still image.
Something needs to be done as you cannot use a fallible system as if it is infallible.
Yep. That decision is a disgrace. The clear blue daylight rule would have meant the VAR check would have taken 5 seconds.
Why don't they try the same rubric for offside the same as the rubric for a penalty: the ref can be asked to review their decision only when there is a clear and obvious error. That would mean clear blue daylight.
Checking every goal for any possible infringement by anyone ever is madness.
Precisely. Precision is meaningless if there is a lack of accuracy.
Yeah I haven't watched a single part of a race since 'that race'.
Football has been nowhere near as bad though. They are messing up the game, but at least goal line technology is working, and VAR does fix some bad decisions.
- Feb 22, 2014
- 2,828
Did the linesman signal offside? I honestly can’t remember. If he didn’t raise his flag however late in the day why do they have to search for a reason to write off goals?
Richy_Seagull
Well-known member
No. Was given as a goal on pitch.
HAILSHAM SEAGULL
Well-known member
- Nov 9, 2009
- 10,359
I'm double gutted, I had a quid on Pervis as 1st goal-scorer at 66/1
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
Sheffield United will dispute the goal line technology working well.
The Fifth Column
Lazy mug
I'm consoling myself with the fact we actually beat Palace 2-1
Yes, this is probably what should happen. If it has taken a few of us a few minutes this morning to elaborate a simple rubric that would certainly reduce the number of egregious errors by a high percentage* why can't these clowns do the same? They fixed the mad handball rubric fairly easily....albeit that too at least half a season.
*Even with clear blue daylight there may be occasions when there is only a millimeter of clear blue daylight, but statistically the chance of this is tiny compared with the 'bodies clearly overlapping' scenario and the 'clearly not overlapping' scenario.
Uh_huh_him
Well-known member
- Sep 28, 2011
- 12,121
It seemed to take an age to tell us that VAR was checking and then an age to check.
As you say it's bizarre.
I often have to do some analysis as part of my job.
When I make an error, more often than not, I spot it quickly, because the data doesn't make sense.
Surely this was the case here, the lines look about a foot apart, but clearly he wasn't that far offside.
But if they missed the mistake, why did it take so long to rule it out?
I just don't understand how they didn't clock their mistake, given all the time it took.
Bob!
Coffee Buyer
- Jul 5, 2003
- 11,630
I'm double gutted, I had a quid on Pervis as 1st goal-scorer at 66/1
I had 2 on Estupinan to score / Brighton to win at 42/1
and 2 on March to score / Brighton to win at 17/2
I'm £100 down!
I'm having a mind blank, what happened? Prior to goal line technology Arsenal were awarded a goal when they completely missed the goal, and one of their players tried to stop it going out for a goal kick - wasn't that against Sheffield Unt?
Aston Villa 0-0 Sheffield United: Visitors denied by tech error on Premier League's return
Report and highlights as Hawk-Eye apologise for goal-line technology error that denied Sheffield United goal on Premier Leagues big return
Villa would have been relegated if they had one less point that season.
Edit to add: I think Bournemouth went down instead?