- Thread starter
- #61
Does feel like it passed the UK by, certainly compared to Friends, and even compared to Curb Your Enthusiasm.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[TV] US Comedy Cup 2024 - NOMINATIONS THREAD
- Thread starter Mellotron
- Start date
hart's shirt
Well-known member
Not sure, but I'll predict that at least one animation will make the Semi-Finals.
- Thread starter
- #63
Frasier seems popular...
- Thread starter
- #65
[TV] - US Comedy Cup 2024 - GROUP STAGE DRAW
presents The US Comedy Cup 2024 - Sponsored by GROUP STAGE DRAW Group A === The Simpsons It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia Archer South Park Group B === Brooklyn Nine-Nine Curb Your Enthusiasm M*A*S*H Police Squad Group C === Arrested Development The Big Bang Theory Flight of the Conchords...
www.northstandchat.com
Can confirm they have avoided each other in the group stages.
JamesAndTheGiantHead
Well-known member
1) Simpsons
2) Parks & Rec
3) South Park
4) Always Sunny
5) WWDITS
My top 5, that absolutely nobody asked for. Seasons 3 - 8 of The Simpsons is the greatest TV ever made, alongside The Sopranos.
2) Parks & Rec
3) South Park
4) Always Sunny
5) WWDITS
My top 5, that absolutely nobody asked for. Seasons 3 - 8 of The Simpsons is the greatest TV ever made, alongside The Sopranos.
studio150
Well-known member
Seeing all the nominations in this thread, just reminds me that American comedy doesn't travel well.
Out of all the nominations, I think I enjoyed three, one of which didn't make the group stage.
No wonder American TV invented canned laughter.
Out of all the nominations, I think I enjoyed three, one of which didn't make the group stage.
No wonder American TV invented canned laughter.
For anyone interested, it's relatively obscure (I think), but The League is v funny IMO. It centres around a bunch of guys who are in a fantasy (American) football league.
Gutted that Modern Family was mentioned too late to be nominated. That would have been my choice to win.
Either South Park or Flight of the Concords from those on the list I reckon.
Thanks for putting it together @Mellotron
Gutted that Modern Family was mentioned too late to be nominated. That would have been my choice to win.
Either South Park or Flight of the Concords from those on the list I reckon.
Thanks for putting it together @Mellotron
- Thread starter
- #70
It missed the cut by the thinnest of margins.
- Thread starter
- #71
The voting in UKCC24 suggested there is a very large OLDER demographic on NSC, which would likely help Homer and co.
Unless you're saying The Simpsons is too recent?!
Well I grew up watching it, and I'm half the age of the typical NSC user.
Based on the way every thread in the UKCC24 featuring Fawlty Towers was full of people calling it dated crap, as it bulldozed its way to the final, I think comedy tastes on here skew slightly older
(see also that many people seemed to think that Blackadder counted as "more recent"
).Maybe it'll be different for American shows.
- Thread starter
- #73
I think it'll be different in that as far as I can see, there are only TWO shows definitely/comfortably older than it in the USCC?Well I grew up watching it, and I'm half the age of the typical NSC user.
Based on the way every thread in the UKCC24 featuring Fawlty Towers was full of people calling it dated crap, as it bulldozed its way to the final, I think comedy tastes on here skew slightly older
(see also that many people seemed to think that Blackadder counted as "more recent"
Maybe it'll be different for American shows.
The Simpsons is one of the oldest shows in this competition, it's prime being the early 90s.
I'd have thought so, but then all the silent geriatrics who vote on these things but never bother writing anything will get wheeled down to the local library to vote for MASH in their droves.
Pevenseagull
meh
- Jul 20, 2003
- 20,668
No Bilko?
Let the sulking begin.
Let the sulking begin.
Is it PotG?
Thrifty non-licker
Hogan's Heroes would give any of these a run for their money.
Kalimantan Gull
Well-known member
So nominations open at 1.34 and close at 2.38, to create a shortlist of best US comedies for us to vote on, and you're telling me that Friends is not one of them?
Well you enjoy your little contest, I'm out
Well you enjoy your little contest, I'm out
- Thread starter
- #78
You see that Italy didn't make the last World Cup? Mad that, wasn't it?So nominations open at 1.34 and close at 2.38, to create a shortlist of best US comedies for us to vote on, and you're telling me that Friends is not one of them?
Well you enjoy your little contest, I'm out
I'd have Friends in a final 16 personally - but this isn't Mellotron's USCC24. It's NSC's.
(See you at the group stages x)
Kalimantan Gull
Well-known member
Well, technically its not NSC's USCC24, its people who happened to be on NSC between 1.34 and 2.38 this afternoon.You see that Italy didn't make the last World Cup? Mad that, wasn't it?
I'd have Friends in a final 16 personally - but this isn't Mellotron's USCC24. It's NSC's.
(See you at the group stages x)
Ironically I happened to be spending that time watching a back-to-back Friends / VEEP / Fresh Prince / 30 Rock medley. That'll teach me/them.....
Pavilionaire
Well-known member
- Jul 7, 2003
- 31,262
I think there were many decent British comedies in the 90s whereas there have been a lot less in the last 10 years or so. Therefore, Curb has gained more traction than Seinfeld did, even though both are Larry David-scripted shows.
I didn't start watching Seinfeld until moved to Australia in 1996 where it was hugely popular. It is a shame it is not better known in the UK - I think the name didn't help because it makes it sound like a shown about one man when in reality it is a sitcom based around a group of 4 characters.