Is this not the same mistake we made when being promoted to the Championship last time? Dick & Co daftly (although with best of intentions) handed out 3 year, from memory, extentions to some players who never really cut it in the higher league.
Not really. Three year extensions is very different to one year. It gives us the option to keep if they have a good season like Barnes/El Abd etc and then allows us a transfer fee for those that don't (Poke/Dicker). The fee isn't then restrictively high because there is only one year left.
All of the players on that list seem sensible and will likely be renewed or not again because they either lived up to expectations or failed to meet the required standard.
Gonna be an exciting summer!!