Trump

[LamieRobertson]

And if they have part time jobs then their taxes go towards funding abortions.

So they have every right to represent the views of tax payers whose taxes fund these abortions if they do not agree with it.

Is it OK for people to have an issue with their taxes funding something they don't agree with? Pretty common reason for people protesting isn't it?

Hmm..private school....doubt very much they have partime jobs which negates the rest of your post

 

[LamieRobertson]

Removed because it was pure lies?

Or removed from some other reason..of course your guess would fit your argument

 

[Tyrone Biggums]

Hmm..private school....doubt very much they have partime jobs which negates the rest of your post

Hmmm It's a Catholic school, hardly prestigious. Most Catholic schools are not full of rich kids. $9000 a year fees, pretty standard for run of the mill lower end private schools these days, most offer part payment methods so working parents can afford it.

Which negates your whole post.

Nice try though.

 

[hans kraay fan club]

Whilst I am pro choice and opposed to the march these kids attended, I fully believe they have a right to attend and wear MAGA hats. That’s their choice. This story has been twisted and that’s pretty sick.

Because everybody has the right to free speech, you don't have to exercise that right

If you don't have a problem with adolescent boys at this demo, I pity you.

I haven't read the whole story, so not sure which is the case, but IMO...

If those boys as individuals chose to attend the rally, then it would be wrong to argue against their right to do so, however much you disagree with the actual protest.

If the school organized or encouraged their attendance at the rally, that would be an entirely different situation, which for me, would be entirely unacceptable.

 

[LamieRobertson]

And if they have part time jobs then their taxes go towards funding abortions.

So they have every right to represent the views of tax payers whose taxes fund these abortions if they do not agree with it.

Is it OK for people to have an issue with their taxes funding something they don't agree with? Pretty common reason for people protesting isn't it?

If.......so you don't know....and I wonder how much tax you would pay on a partime job if any.....hmm..negates the rest of the post

 

[LamieRobertson]

I haven't read the whole story, so not sure which is the case, but IMO...

If those boys as individuals chose to attend the rally, then it would be wrong to argue against their right to do so, however much you disagree with the actual protest.

If the school organized or encouraged their attendance at the rally, that would be an entirely different situation, which for me, would be entirely unacceptable.

Perhaps we need to wait for the facts

 

[Tyrone Biggums]

If.......so you don't know....and I wonder how much tax you would pay on a partime job if any.....hmm..negates the rest of the post

And either do you. But their parents pay taxes and parents always have to sign off on school excursions. So there's their proxy representatives protesting on their behalf.

Too easy.

 

[LamieRobertson]

And either do you. But their parents pay taxes and parents always have to sign off on school excursions. So there's their proxy representatives protesting on their behalf.

Too easy.

Talk about stretching something to fit an argument..prox my arse
...yeah you are too easy to read

 

[Tyrone Biggums]

Talk about stretching something to fit an argument..prox my arse
...yeah you are too easy to read

If their parents didn't want them there protesting they wouldn't be there. #facts

 

[LamieRobertson]

If their parents didn't want them there protesting they wouldn't be there. #facts

Lol..children of course always do what their parents want

....and the facts I'd say are still to come out....you are guessing to suit your own agenda.

 

[BadFish]

Perhaps we need to wait for the facts

Nah, much better to leap to a conclusion that furthers our agenda and belt out our thoughts to our echo chamber.

 

[hans kraay fan club]

And either do you. But their parents pay taxes and parents always have to sign off on school excursions. So there's their proxy representatives protesting on their behalf.
.

You're clutching at straws now.

Plain and simple - a SCHOOL (Catholic or otherwise) should not be sending / encouraging / facilitating their students attending political rallies - especially one of a nature as divisive as this. If indeed that were the case, it would be a utterly abominable misuse of their influence on those children, and of their funds.

If an Islamic faith school here (or in Geelong) was bussing children to demonstrate at Remembrance Day ceremonies, at protest against UK / Aus forces military actions in the Middle East, you would presumably be completely cool with that? (So long as their parents pay tax, obviously )

 

[Tyrone Biggums]

Lol..children of course always do what their parents want

....and the facts I'd say are still to come out....you are guessing to suit your own agenda.

They aren't children. They are young adults.

I've not made a statement in any way in regards to who is wrong or right. I simply responded as to why they can be protesting. Nothing about the actual incident.

Keep up at the back.

 

[LamieRobertson]

They aren't children. They are young adults.

I've not made a statement in any way in regards to who is wrong or right. I simply responded as to why they can be protesting. Nothing about the actual incident.

Keep up at the back.

Lol...makes it worse...since when did 'young adults' always do what their parents say ...lets go back to the original point....acting as proxy..as has been said clutching at straws.....

Regarding agenda....hmm....havn't seen you much on the Albion related posts

PS ttfn off to work

 

[Tyrone Biggums]

You're clutching at straws now.

Plain and simple - a SCHOOL (Catholic or otherwise) should not be sending / encouraging / facilitating their students attending political rallies - especially one of a nature as divisive as this. If indeed that were the case, it would be a utterly abominable misuse of their influence on those children, and of their funds.

Is it simply political or is it morally based? I'd say there's a large moral component present.

So you'd be dead against anyone young turning up to an anti-war rally then going by what you just stated. Plenty of young people the same age as these youths turning up to environmental protests and rallies with the encouragement of their teachers these days. Is that acceptable?

If an Islamic faith school here (or in Geelong) was bussing children to demonstrate at Remembrance Day ceremonies, at protest against UK / Aus forces military actions in the Middle East, you would presumably be completely cool with that? (So long as their parents pay tax, obviously )

I would. I'd think them complete cock heads, but that's how democratic society works. Everyone gets to have their say do they not?

I've quoted this line in its various forms a few times on this site...

I do not agree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to

 

[Tyrone Biggums]

Lol...makes it worse...since when did 'young adults' always do what their parents say ...lets go back to the original point....acting as proxy..as has been said clutching at straws.....

Regarding agenda....hmm....havn't seen you much on the Albion related posts

PS ttfn off to work

When you start work at 10pm and finish at 5am on weekends it's a bit hard to be on a website keeping people like you content of ones super fan status.

I reckon the previous 30+ years staying up late should allow me some grace on that front.

 

[Stat Brother]

Pro choice clinics have all but been outlawed in the state of Kentucky, so none of these porn-addled (except one, there's always one weirdo) children, half of which probably already have erectile disfunction, taxation from their paper rounds goes to fund abortion clinics.

 

[Ex-Staffs Gull]

Right, I have spent a little time reviewing what is known about this event now some dust has settled. I have altered my view a bit and here is why.

I hate pro-life MAGA chanting kids, I also hate Trump. I dont know anything about the black Israelites, but assume like most religions, they are fairly judgemental and preachy. The NA are clearly trying to raise awareness of land issues they feel strongly about.

Both the NA and Black Israelites would both have loved publicity for their causes.

There is plenty of doubt about what happened and videos can be deceptive, and although I hate Trump and the MAGA movement, I have read more around the circumstances and hold that these MAGA kids had as much right to demonstrate and had a legitimate reason for wearing that hideous red stuff, just as the NA and the Black Israelites had the same rights.

So apologies for jumping on a pre conception at first, but I still believe it is a sad reflection on our society that this is even a thing.

Saying that, the Kid facing off the NA with a drum was definitely grand standing, not defusing.

 

[hans kraay fan club]

I haven't read the whole story, so not sure which is the case, but IMO...

If those boys as individuals chose to attend the rally, then it would be wrong to argue against their right to do so, however much you disagree with the actual protest.

If the school organized or encouraged their attendance at the rally, that would be an entirely different situation, which for me, would be entirely unacceptable.

So you'd be dead against anyone young turning up to an anti-war rally then going by what you just stated.

Do you struggle with comprehension?

 

[The_Viper]

I didn't have to look it up, but in the interests of real news I thought I should.


Colvington Catholic High School is an ALL MALE high school.

If you don't have a problem with men telling women what to with their bodies - you should

If you don't have a problem with adolescent boys telling women what to do with their bodies - you are one sick individual.

Okay Google what's a strawman argument?