[NSC] Tie off vote for new competition

[TomandJerry]

After a score draw in the first thread it comes down to the two final options.

The one with the highest score will have a competition run in its name.

Get voting!

 

[The Mole]

Best bisc will be really controversial and get some heated comments

best albion goal celebration is Leo at forest … boring

 

[TomandJerry]

Best bisc will be really controversial and get some heated comments

best albion goal celebration is Leo at forest … boring

World's best biscuit is running away with the vote so far...

 

[Mellotron]

Definitely world’s best biscuit - chance for a lot of Binfestery in that.

How many for a tourney though? 32 is too many. 16 and 4 groups of 4 perhaps?

I would also - just personal preference - call it the Biscuit World Cup (BWC24), leaving it open for future iterations in later years.

 

[MattBackHome]

Threw in a vote for Goal Celebrations even though it won't win because I can think of a few underrated classics. But yeah biscuits will be good too.

 

[TomandJerry]

Definitely world’s best biscuit - chance for a lot of Binfestery in that.

How many for a tourney though? 32 is too many. 16 and 4 groups of 4 perhaps?

I would also - just personal preference - call it the Biscuit World Cup (BWC24), leaving it open for future iterations in later years.

The amount of entries depends on how many get voted in and seconded, it's purely down to NSC as to how many 'biscuits' will be entered into the competition

 

[Nobby Cybergoat]

The amount of entries depends on how many get voted in and seconded, it's purely down to NSC as to how many 'biscuits' will be entered into the competition

As long as jaffa cake is there, i'm sure there'll be no controversy

 

[Trevor]

Voted biscuit.
I don't like a pre-meditated goal celebration at all

But I do like biscuits

 

[TomandJerry]

As long as jaffa cake is there, i'm sure there'll be no controversy

The vote will be free and open. If the great NSC vote for the Jaffa Cake then it'll be included into the competition

 

[Greg Bobkin]

The vote will be free and open. If the great NSC vote for the Jaffa Cake then it'll be included into the competition

Even if it's not a biscuit? The comp will be flawed from the start.

Shambles.

 

[Is it PotG?]

World's best biscuit is running away with the vote so far...

Oh crumbs, but that's Nice.

 

[TomandJerry]

Even if it's not a biscuit? The comp will be flawed from the start.

Shambles.

It's a mix of a badly run competition with a non existent ruling of what defines a biscuit as a biscuit.


Though I'm thinking after this vote finishes I'll make another poll asking if NSC wants a biscuit definition or if NSC wants a free for all within the biscuit competition

Though if NSC wants a overall definition of what defines a biscuit as a biscuit I fear that will lead to heated debate before the start of the nomation thread!

All very complicated, this biscuit competition lark

 

[jakarta]

To celebrate the Biscuits likely victory I have just had a couple of McVities Dark Chocolate Digestives..

 

[Is it PotG?]

As a rough guide, when they go 'off', your biscuit goes soft and your cake (Jaffa Cake) goes hard.

Does biscuits include the individually wrapped ones, if so Breakaway has won?

 

[Bry Nylon]

Whichever theme is ultimately selected, at least it will give me the opportunity to give the 'ignore thread(s)' functionality a thorough road test.

 

[Questions]

Worlds best biscuit and sexual position was a good thread years ago.

 

[Trevor]

As a rough guide, when they go 'off', your biscuit goes soft and your cake (Jaffa Cake) goes hard.

Yes, that was the legal ruling. Was is to do with VAT?

Maybe a favourite thing you can Dunk thread

 

[Mellotron]

The amount of entries depends on how many get voted in and seconded, it's purely down to NSC as to how many 'biscuits' will be entered into the competition

Surely better to set a reasonable (and easily divisible - 16, 24, 32 etc) number and then close nominations once that many have been seconded?

Would be easier to run than something that gets to an unwieldy number - I’m just thinking of the admin burden for you, speaking from experience!

 

[Blue3]

Worlds best biscuit and the the obvious answer is Bourbon

 

[TomandJerry]

Surely better to set a reasonable (and easily divisible - 16, 24, 32 etc) number and then close nominations once that many have been seconded?

Would be easier to run than something that gets to an unwieldy number - I’m just thinking of the admin burden for you, speaking from experience!

Absolutely, perhaps I'll set a limit on the nomination to thread, once we hit a certain amount of biscuits that have been seconded then it closes. All the favorites should then be in the running