The "will he/won't he Noone to Cardiff" thread

[pottert]

Shame, but he has neither the end product of Buckley or the pure pace of LuaLua, so, given we only play one winger, he won't be missed as sorely as some might think.

f*** OFF

Buckley is doing well at the moment but he is reliant on pace the same as lua lua.noone gives us a different option where he uses skill to beat a player.
The more options we have the better we will be.before he got injured noone had been 1 of our best players this season so why would we want to sell him

 

[Seagull on the wing]

Agree..amazing player,lousy singer,danm nice guy...if true it would be a shame but at least the fee is more reasonable now from that derisory first offer of £450,000...if he goes...good luck Nooney.

 

[RickofBHAFC]

If Noone has gone to you then that's football - good luck to you!

Bluebird on behalf of all Brighton fans well done for denying the Palace scum the chance of a Wembley appearance and sincerely hope you do the dirty scousers!

We of course had our own superb result against the geordies today and hopefully will get a result against the scum tuesday night . . .

 

[blockhseagull]

Doesn't sound like he is going anywhere judging by his tweets

 

[GoldWithFalmer]

I will go against the grain here and say if we get anything approaching £1m for Noone we will have done well,if the player is happy to go to a good Cardiff sqaud so be it,do we need to sell? perhaps not but does Craig have potential or has he reached his level,however good he may be,what of his injury?perhaps nothing,could we do better,well of course,but should we sell? if we sell,we sell for a reason,i am one for keeping players,but unhappy players must be let go,however in this instance is Craig unhappy?perhaps not,is his wife/partner happy and settled? this can often be a reason for a player to make a move......so many factors,we must move on and i trust Gus to find a replacement.

If Craig remains at Brighton,it's still a win win situation.....we will recoup upto 3 times our outlay......the Gus bus rolls forward..

 

[HantsSeagull]

He's probably tired from all the travelling today

no doubt. I wonder if he feels like the rest of us when crossing the bridge. You would be happy to pay to get out of Wales but making you pay to get in.....

 

[HAILSHAM SEAGULL]

Keep posting tosser, cos if Noonie reads this, and sees what sort of wankers follow Cardiff, then he will turn the move down like a shot.

 

[Bluebird99]

If Noone has gone to you then that's football - good luck to you!

Bluebird on behalf of all Brighton fans well done for denying the Palace scum the chance of a Wembley appearance and sincerely hope you do the dirty scousers!
We of course had our own superb result against the geordies today and hopefully will get a result against the scum tuesday night . . .

Great to talk to a mature fan. Firstly, massive well done on the result today and trust me, after Dougies poor attempts at mind games, you you will have one extra Brighton fan that night. Someone take a sling shot for that bloody bird they let fly around!

 

[pottert]

Doesn't sound like he is going anywhere judging by his tweets

Agree

 

[the right footed denilson]

f*** OFF

Buckley is doing well at the moment but he is reliant on pace the same as lua lua.noone gives us a different option where he uses skill to beat a player.
The more options we have the better we will be.before he got injured noone had been 1 of our best players this season so why would we want to sell him

Fair enough. Sportsmans bet that both KLL and Buckley are playing at a higher level than Noone in 5 seasons time?
Beating a player is fine, but you have to actually do something with the ball.
EDIT. I don't for one second think Nooney is crap, i just think we have other, better options and perhaps he doesn't fit in with Poyets style of play quite as much as we'd like.
People think we have an endless amount of money, and maybe we do, but anyone would be mad to turn down close to a mil for a guy likely to be on the bench more than starting.

 

[Bluebird99]

Keep posting tosser, cos if Noonie reads this, and sees what sort of wankers follow Cardiff, then he will turn the move down like a shot.

Or he will see poor replies from some of your "fans" and realise why it's a step up!

 

[Surrey Phil]

More than happy to, I'd also give younthe exact reasons why it didn't happen just before my ban. However, it won't comemtonthat as younwill see in the next 24 hours

Your talking welsh again - translate please.

 

[C1 BHA]

Noone going nowhere FACT. He loves it here. Wants to play in the Prem, for The Albion.

 

[Bluebird99]

Your talking welsh again - translate please.

HE'S SIGNING FOR CARDIFF CITY TOMORROW.....understand?

 

[Lush]

He's probably tired from all the travelling today

Although he wasn't playing or on the bench as not quite recovered from injury, he walked out on the pitch with the players at about 3.45.

 

[collins91]

his twitter says he was at the game

 

[Bluebird99]

Anyway, I'm off for the night now lads and ladettes! I will be back tomorrow evening, enjoy the next 20 hours or so won't you!

 

[Horton's halftime iceberg]

Noone loving the Albion, he will get plenty of interest from big Premership clubs. Will be amazed if he leaves at present, especially when we will invest further in the team.

Gus bus is on the move, all aboard.

 

[Willy Dangle]

You again. f*** off.

You really are a short jab of the pointed end of a needle.

 

[Ninja Elephant]

Not sure it is rubbish. He does has something different, but when fit he would be third choice. So, it's perhaps a luxury we don't need at the moment.
If, for the money reported, we sign Wallace and Vokes, i'd say it's a VERY good bit of business.
We can't promise him first team football and he doesn't play a position that lends itself to Poyet's formation and style of play.
Just my opinion like.

Unfortunately, our opinions on Noone himself differ, but our opinion overall is exactly the same. It would be good business, considering the squad we have available and the players we want to bring in, it would make sense. It's just a shame, I think he's our most exciting player by quite some way.