The Argus greatest XI

[BensGrandad]

From Todays Argus Supplement

Gk Kuszczak agree
RB Calderon what about Tennant, Tiler, Chivers dont ageee
LB Bridge possibly or Langley
CB Foster agree
CB Lawrenson agree
RMF Penney agree
CMF Horton agree
CMF Vicente agree
LMF O' Sullivan agree
Striker Ward agree
Striker Zamora agree

It must be 15-20 year olds voting to make Calderon our best ever right back

 

[Whitechapel]

I'd have Ben Roberts over Kuszczak...

 

[GingerBeerMan]

From Todays Argus Supplement

Gk Kuszczak agree
RB Calderon what about Tennant, Tiler, Chivers dont ageee
LB Bridge possibly or Langley
CB Foster agree
CB Lawrenson agree
RMF Penney agree
CMF Horton agree
CMF Vicente agree
LMF O' Sullivan agree
Striker Ward agree
Striker Zamora agree

It must be 15-20 year olds voting to make Calderon our best ever right back

Calderon's not even our best right back now.

 

[dennis]

There are so many better keepers than PIG.

Peter Grummit was the best then Eric Steele, Graham Moseley John Keeley and even Perry Digweed on his day. FDM I would put them all above.

 

[Skaville]

You could make a fairly good case for Paul Watson too, certainly from an offensive perspective.

 

[BensGrandad]

There are so many better keepers than PIG.

Peter Grummit was the best then Eric Steele, Graham Moseley John Keeley and even Perry Digweed on his day. FDM I would put them all above.

They are all possible including Eric Gill but I would just go for TK, for me he edges it. I agree with Paul Watson as a better right back than Calderon.

 

[Honky Tonx]

Sergei Gotsmanov instead of Horton and Grummitt in goal. Why is Robbie Savage not included?

 

[Mackenzie]

Sergei Gotsmanov instead of Horton and Grummitt in goal. Why is Robbie Savage not included?

Robbie Savage had a good career, but he was disappointing when he played for us on loan.

 

[One hot tub one ambition]

Jimmy Case?

 

[Hampster Gull]

Steele over K

 

[Herne Bay Gull]

Brian Powney?

 

[gjh1971]

You could make a fairly good case for Paul Watson too, certainly from an offensive perspective.

And John Gregory

 

[Saladpack Seagull]

I'd have Ben Roberts over Kuszczak...

I'd have Graham Moseley over both of them. Played in the top division against the best strikers in the country. Legend.

 

[dennis]

I'd have Graham Moseley over both of them. Played in the top division against the best strikers in the country. Legend.

While I don't disagree with your answer, I disagree with your reason.

My best players have been when we were in Division 3.

Gummit, Ward, Mellor, Nobby and then 10 years later

Keeley, Rougvie, Dublin, Bremner and Nelson.

Fantastic times.

 

[northstandsteve]

Grummitt for me, i'll put Stevens at right back.

 

[catfish]

Grummitt for me, i'll put Stevens at right back.

Good call on both.

 

[dangull]

Vicente great talent, but not sure he played enough games compared for example Jimmy Case who scored the winner in the Q/F and a cracking goal in the S/F in helping Brighton getting to the cup final.

 

[elbowpatches]

Nelson and Robinson were my favourite players growing up. Surprised not to see either feature.

 

[GT49er]

Stevens a better player than Foster in defence for me - Foster was an icon, but not actually that good!

Not sure about Vicente either - both because he didn't play enough and because if we're playing 442 he wasn't the right player for CM. Nobby Lawton, perhaps, or Brian Bromley. And Tony Towner on the right.

 

[BadFish]

Vicente great talent, but not sure he played enough games compared for example Jimmy Case who scored the winner in the Q/F and a cracking goal in the S/F in helping Brighton getting to the cup final.

in terms of talent maybe vicente deserves to be in there but surely as far as game time and influence goes Case would be a much better call.