The 100 worst Albion players of all time

[Russell Slade's hat]

Phil Stant.

 

[Gerbil]

Mccamon

 

[Gerbil]

Gavin Hoyte
Edit: Should have read the rules first

 

[Gwylan]

There are some bizarre choices here: Mark Farrington and Chris Ramsay both played in higher divisions (and even Willie Young, while poor, was probably better than most of those mentioned). And Kitson only played a handful of games for us but still scored two goals.

And would the John Crumplin be the same John Crumplin that was in Albion's all-time best XI as nominated by Argus readers a couple of years back?


And two pages and no-one's mentioned Gislason yet?

How about the Fox brothers?
Geoff Cooper?
Bertie Lutton?

 

[Arthur]

Mark Walton
Kerry Mayo
Andy Kennedy
Ashley Neale
The days he didn't want to play Robert Codnor
Zesh Rayman
John Byrne's second stint

 

[Austrian Gull]

Darren Carr
Glen Thomas
Jamie Moralee
Christer Warren
Nicky Rust

 

[Jimbo26]

Justin Fashanu weren't much cop

 

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

Phil Stant.

Phil Stant

(so bad they named him twice)

 

[Lardinho]

Teddy Maybank

 

[Mendoza]

Valur Gislason
David Adekola
Jason Peake
Kevin McGarrigle
Scott Thomas
Steve Barnes
Geoff Woosley
Joe Dolan

 

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

Geoff Pitcher - well I'm guessing he was. Don't believe I actually ever saw him play for the Albion cos he was sent out on loan for about five years and most of us just assumed he'd died or something

 

[FLOG GNAW]

Mark Walton
Kerry Mayo
Andy Kennedy
Ashley Neale
The days he didn't want to play Robert Codnor
Zesh Rayman Didn't think he was great but not one of the worst either
John Byrne's second stint

Graham Barrett is the worst player I have seen play, 30 games 1 goal.

 

[Working class pride]

Robbie Savage - did he touch the ball when he was here? Also Nicky Rust, although that may seem harsh.

 

[BensGrandad]

Mickey Thomas complete with reputation.

 

[Martinf]

And would the John Crumplin be the same John Crumplin that was in Albion's all-time best XI as nominated by Argus readers a couple of years back?

Yes - he was utter cack.

 

[Spider]

Sam Williams was possibly the worst striker I can remember playing for Brighton (ie, Withdean years). Seem to remember George Santos having a couple of shockers as well but I can't say he was in the 100 worst of all time!

 

[wigman]

Mickey Thomas complete with reputation.

Good call BG,i remember him signing for us only for him to say he regretted coming here a day or so after he had put pen to paper.

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Paul "Injured again" Kitson!!

Disagree, when he played he was class.

Disagree with Mcphee as well, he scored a few goals in the play off year

 

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

Disagree with Mcphee has well, he scored a few goals n the play off year

McPhee also contributed to about half of Leon (He's Alright ) Knight's goal total that season by habitually being slow and clumsy in the box and ending up on his arse and being awarded a penalty

 

[fosters headband]

Wayne Henderson
Mark Flatts