Teixiera or Lingard

[spring hall convert]

positional sense and intelligence.

Those were the attributes I most remember. His positional awareness and off the ball running were exceptional for a young player. He always seemed to be in space that he had created for himself - he worked very well as part of a fluid front 3, he seemed to understand what Garcia wanted more than the players that had been here all year.

Not sure he'll make it at United but let's face it, who does now? He find a home in the Premier League though, underrated by many on here.

 

[Marshy]

Pretty much, but Tex is blessed with far more skill and ability than Lingard, IMO.

Not for me, but hey ho I am used to not agreeing with the majority it seems

Lingard is a much better player all round for me.

 

[8ace]

The effect of recency is completely illustrated in this poll. Lingard had a far better loan spell than Teixiera overall but Teixiera's just had an excellent game.

Football fans being the knee jerk reactionary sorts plump for the guy who's been massively inconsistent and is easily kicked out of games.

If the question was who has the potential to be a better player it would be Teixera, no doubt. However, in the here and now I'd have Lingard.

I don't doubt that there is some recency bias in the voting in this poll, but it's also worth noting that JL wasn't revered universally at the time.

 

[DarrenFreemansPerm]

Not for me, but hey ho I am used to not agreeing with the majority it seems

Lingard is a much better player all round for me.

It would be boring if we all had the same opinion.

I see your signature, is that still relevant or do you still believe in CMS?

 

[leigull]

I think people are getting very carried away with 1 excellent performance against Ipswich from Tex.

Had this pole been done a week ago I am pretty confident the results would be reversed.

Lingard for me was a much more consisitently high performer than Tex. And a much bigger goal threat

Those were my thoughts too. Everyone thought he was rubbish after his form from the first few games faded away. Though we may see Teixeira turn in those Ipswich like performances a bit more regularly under Hughton now.

 

[spring hall convert]

I don't doubt that there is some recency bias in the voting in this poll, but it's also worth noting that JL wasn't revered universally at the time.

Yup. There's an interesting point to be made about swapping them over. Funnily enough, I reckon Lingard would have stood out more with how we've been this year and Teixiera would have been far more effective in the space created by a decent target man.

I look forward to seeing Hughton unlock the obvious potential in Tex. If he does, we have one hell of a player.

 

[Munkfish]

teixiera he seems to want to be involved rather than looking as if it is a temp loan until he is in the 1st team

How many times have you seen either of them play to make that observation?

 

[Justice]

Lindgard isn't coming back pointless thread, you might as well have a poll for CMS or Messi.

 

[Pogue Mahone]

Lindgard isn't coming back pointless thread, you might as well have a poll for CMS or Messi.

Eh? It's an interesting thread, comparing two attacking players loaned in from two top Premier League sides in successive seasons. It's not about getting Lingard back.

Can't see why you would get hot under the collar about a thread such as this.

 

[spring hall convert]

Lindgard isn't coming back pointless thread, you might as well have a poll for CMS or Messi.

God knows what you'd make of the World's Hardest Creatures polls.

 

[BensGrandad]

Lindgard isn't coming back pointless thread, you might as well have a poll for CMS or Messi.

Eh? It's an interesting thread, comparing two attacking players loaned in from two top Premier League sides in successive seasons. It's not about getting Lingard back.

Can't see why you would get hot under the collar about a thread such as this.

Possibly to do with who compiled the poll ! I viewed in the same light as you Pogue Mahone

 

[8ace]

Calling all Lingard lickers!

 

[BensGrandad]

On last nights showing we have the best one.

 

[perseus]

I changed my mind to Tex early on into the Leeds game. I prefer Lualua to both of them.

 

[BensGrandad]

I changed my mind early on into the Leeds game. I prefer Lualua to both of them.

Your next joke, Tiexiera says about leaving Liverpool and if he does a lower Premier side or relegated side to the Championship will come in for him but alwats hopeful it could be us.

 

[Hampster Gull]

Tex. ling has moved on

 

[Quinney]

Tex all day long

 

[OzMike]

Tex = flair, no brainer.

 

[DavidinSouthampton]

Teixeira - but Lingard is easier to spell.

 

[Jim Bob]

Tex for me, but could we not just sign the both of them in the summer pleaseeeeee