Star Trek Vs Star Wars

[Oscar]

I love Star Wars and quite like Star Trek but which one is better? There's only one way to find out...

 

[brakespear]

Great video, the right result too

 

[Ulloa's Soul Patch]

That video was brilliant. Star Wars is my favourite, can't stand Trek

 

[L2MidgetGem B.H.A Seagull]

Star Trek all the way. Starwars Has become kiddyfied and with Disney owning them now It's only going to get more family friendly.

 

[jakarta]

Star Wars is Cowboys and Indians in Space, with impressive visuals but cloth eared and plodding dialogue, whereas the 1960's Star Trek had episodes written by established SF writers such as Harlan Ellison and Theodore Sturgeon. Still everyone to their own....

 

[HastingsSeagull]

Star Wars is much better.

Not convinced by video but bit different. Thanks for posting

 

[beorhthelm]

star wars obviously. star trek gets too PC.

 

[LeicestershireGull]

The only logical answer is Trek.

 

[JamesAndTheGiantHead]

WARS, no contest.

And Im only counting the original trilogy.

 

[Ulloa's Soul Patch]

WARS, no contest.

And Im only counting the original trilogy.

The new Star Wars were a disgrace to the original trilogy!

 

[Cheeky Monkey]

WARS, no contest.

And Im only counting the original trilogy.

100% 'This'

 

[Fungus]

Trek! (Not the latest one, though)

 

[JBizzle]

WARS, no contest.

And Im only counting the original trilogy.

If those are the rules then Trek but I'm only counting the Wrath of Khan.

Seriously though it's definately Trek. Lucas has simply ruined the originals by revising them so often and making truly abysmal prequels.

 

[fruitnveg]

 

[dangull]

Star treck for me. Seems more believable that this could happen in the future apart from the beaming down onto planets etc. Star wars seems more for a younger audiance and cant see a character as Darth Vader as being believable.

 

[Green Cross Code Man]

Star treck for me. Seems more believable that this could happen in the future apart from the beaming down onto planets etc. Star wars seems more for a younger audiance and cant see a character as Darth Vader as being believable.

The 'beaming down' part is theoretically possible. Scientists have already 'beamed' particles elsewhere quite successfully!

 

[dangull]

The 'beaming down' part is theoretically possible. Scientists have already 'beamed' particles elsewhere quite successfully!

Thanks for that, i think i saw something about that, but to disassmble a whole body atom by atom then put it all together on the planet below perfectly seems a bit tricky, but you never know in the 24th century !

 

[chrissyboy01]

This is clearly a 'no brainer'. Star Wars hands down. Apparently it's also 'arrys favourite film too. Is this a sign?

 

[nomoremithras4me]

Star Wars for me, purely based on a light sabre! To this day, I desperately hope some brainiac comes up with one

 

[portlock seagull]

This question is Currently being debated on Five Live.
I’ve been a lifelong SW fan (originals) so would always be Team SW.
However, the sheer volume of SW ‘dross’ that’s been launched since this thread was started, is making me want to vote ST in protest!