Sin bins ..should we have them in soccer

[CAFC Matt]

Yes for diving and rolling aroundon floor. Also for dissent and stupid things like that which don't really warrant a yellow card but deserve a punishment

 

[Jason Speaks]

Anyone up on Hockey rules.

Don't they have a green card to be issued for forms of cheating and a yellow for foul play.

I may be wrong.

 

[Mr C]

Can we get sin bins at the same time as the players get two-way radios on the pitch?

 

[seagull over sevenoaks]

great idea.. We should defiently do it.. and while we're at it can we put some yardage markers on the pitch too.. maybe make the players wear full body armour. Abolish offside and make the goals bigger...

or we could just leave it as it is

 

[¤DãŃn¥ §êãGüLL¤]

No - it could give the offending team an advantage. It's easy enough to sit back and defend with 10 men then start pressing forward again once the player returns freash as a daisy from his 10 minute breather.

 

[Brighton Boy]

If a player fouls a member of the opposition he should have to have 2 shots of vodka.

Keane would be f***ed by the end of the match.

HA HA HA

 

[Robot Chicken]

Just get the offending player to run around the touchline carrying weights.

This has two advantages.
1) There would be no chance for the player to relax.
2) If you get sent to the sin bin, each subsequent time means heavier weights.

If you don't run round the touchline you won't be allowed back on the pitch. If you're a persistant offender you may find yourself in the position of having to actually carry more than you weigh. In that case, tough.

 

[graz126]

Just get the offending player to run around the touchline carrying weights.

This has two advantages.
1) There would be no chance for the player to relax.
2) If you get sent to the sin bin, each subsequent time means heavier weights.

If you don't run round the touchline you won't be allowed back on the pitch. If you're a persistant offender you may find yourself in the position of having to actually carry more than you weigh. In that case, tough.

like it. not 1 for too much change. but why should the victims get punished by having 10 men for upto 10 mins.