[Football] Should we scrap the offside rule?

[Brovion]

I know this often comes up when people talk about 'rule changes I'd like to see', but I've never been in favour, no, not even if it meant one less thing for VAR to pass judgement on.

However apparently the Dutch are thinking of trying it in their non-league. As an aside I didn't realise the problem of violence and abuse wasn't just an English problem.

Dutch FA considers scrapping offside in amateur football to end violent rows

The KNVB says abolishing offside would bring fewer rows, with violent incidents on the rise in the Netherlands

www.theguardian.com

 

[Coldeanseagull]

No

 

[Clive Walker]

....and close thread.

 

[Greg Bobkin]

Not for me, Clive.

 

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

There was a competition called the Dryborough Cup in Scotland in the 1970s that experimented with a variation of the offside rule. The 18 yard line was extended to the touchlines and you could only be offside within that area. Could be workable if reintroduced?

 

[The Optimist]

Not in the professional game no. Shouldn’t have to happen in the amateur game either, but if a minority can’t behave and it fixes a problem then I can see why it’s being considered.

 

[Muzzman]

The scores would be silly... bet the yanks would love it.

It's one of the best rules in football along with the backpass rule.

 

[Guinness Boy]

Absolutely not with our high line

 

[SAC]

No. Players, and fans, have got to realise that the officials are doing the best they can.

We have gone from the refs getting decisions wrong, to VAR getting some decisions wrong, to VAR being too accurate.

 

[beorhthelm]

of course not, only thing needs changing is go back to simple offside with no phases, active players crap.

suggest Netherlands have deeper issues around violence if games are abandoned over an offside decision.

 

[Swegulls]

Well, I would like to see what it would look like before I say yes or no. It would be really interesting. Probably sh*te, but ...

 

[Wozza]

Nope.

 

[Guinness Boy]

Well, I would like to see what it would look like before I say yes or no. It would be really interesting. Probably sh*te, but ...

You know that kid at school who played "goal hanger" and everyone just tried to lump it to him?*

Well, it'll look like that.


*I appreciate you're Swedish so maybe not!

 

[Super Steve Earle]

of course not, only thing needs changing is go back to simple offside with no phases, active players crap.

suggest Netherlands have deeper issues around violence if games are abandoned over an offside decision.

Agree with you about offside and same for handball too. Handball needs to always be handball, not based on an algorithm.

 

[dazzer6666]

 

[Brovion]

of course not, only thing needs changing is go back to simple offside with no phases, active players crap.

suggest Netherlands have deeper issues around violence if games are abandoned over an offside decision.

Yeah that's my take on it. I was more surprised about the level of violence in the Dutch amateur game tbh. It must be really bad if they're even considering it.

 

[Nobby Cybergoat]

You know that kid at school who played "goal hanger" and everyone just tried to lump it to him?*

Well, it'll look like that.

30 years ago, that is exactly what would have happened.

Now i'm much less sure.

I reckon the game would be more similar to what we see now than most here think. Fair that high lines would be a thing of the past, but I don't see that teams would be stationing 4 x 6 foot blokes on the 6 yard box and putting it in the mixer, that's conceding the midfield.

Got to say i'm not 100% sure what would happen and I reckon different manager's would approach the new rules in very different ways, but I reckon we would still primarily be a passing through the middle / quick break sort of team

 

[mejonaNO12 aka riskit]

Thinking about it, it would be such a mind f*** to play in. I'm 38, am RUBBISH but I all I've known is to 'bend' your run when trying to get in behind the defence. Give the passer the knowing look, run in front of the defence and then feel like you've SLINGSHOT through on goal as the pass is made to try and stay onside but run with momentum.

I genuinely don't know how I'd cope. I guess you just don't care about the timing so much but it would feel DIRTY.

 

[Swegulls]

You know that kid at school who played "goal hanger" and everyone just tried to lump it to him?*

Well, it'll look like that.


*I appreciate you're Swedish so maybe not!

It would certainly turn tactics as we know it upside down. Hoof ball? How to defend? Go back to some kind of libero? Man - man? Dump and chase a la NHL!? I'd like to see a game anyway.

 

[Han Solo]