[Albion] Should we appeal the Propper red?

[BensGrandad]

I think that we should appeal it as we have nothing to lose as it is unlikely to be considered a frivolous appeal and an extra game added.

 

[aolstudios]

Didn't Pritchard put the boot in with the ref?

Yep, Dunk (a little recklessly) pushed him away

 

[portslade seagull]

Looked a good 50/50 from WSU. Surprised he was sent off. Sadly the appeal Will be a waste of time as the panel always sides with the ref

 

[hart's shirt]

Having seen Ashley Young's 2 footed tackle on Aguero that got nothing and should have been a penalty and red card, it's definitely worth appealing.

 

[Sarisbury Seagull]

Yes but I doubt it will be overturned.

Massive loss for the next 3 games.

 

[Weststander]

Having seen Ashley Young's 2 footed tackle on Aguero that got nothing and should have been a penalty and red card, it's definitely worth appealing.

Shocker from Atkinson. Stone wall penalty and red card for violence. Even Gary Neville said so, both before and after the slow-mo replay.

We got lucky today though when Duffy should've got a second yellow for taking out their player on the counter down the wing. A challenge he didn't need to make, in a rubbish performance. Talk of him walking into top PL club defences was fanciful.

 

[Thunder Bolt]

Yeah, let's give the FA the chance to make it 5.

Never get overturned but given it's end of season and I don't think we've appealed anything so far, why not.

Calde's red card was after a 50/50 challenge & the bloke broke his leg.

No we don't. And no it isn't - it is the club recognising it's completely pointless, and actually risks a longer suspension.

We've appealed there or four red cards in recent years without any further suspensions.
It's worth a try, but I don't think it will be overturned.

 

[OzMike]

No, it will force some changes for a win maybe.

 

[Seasider78]

No, it will force some changes for a win maybe.

Or leave us with a just fit Stephens and Kayal as our only central midfield options

 

[DavidinSouthampton]

We have to. Otherwise the club is agreeing that it was a red.

Disagree. We would just be weighing up whether it is worth bothering.

 

[brightn'ove]

Calde's red card was after a 50/50 challenge & the bloke broke his leg.



We've appealed there or four red cards in recent years without any further suspensions.
It's worth a try, but I don't think it will be overturned.

This.

It is not frivolous as there is debate around it. Frivolous would be appealing an off the ground over the ball studs up leg breaker.

This is very similar to the Calde red card imo.

 

[The Birdman]

Split decision on match of the day.

 

[Blue3]

Just seen on MOTD I think it's well worth an appeal only looks bad as the Huddersfield player spins round like spinning top and make

 

[Icy Gull]

If we can’t even agree amongst ourselves I think you can take it that we have absolutely no chance of it being overturned. I’d be surprised if they extended it by a game though so got to be worth a try.

 

[Quinney]

If we can’t even agree amongst ourselves I think you can take it that we have absolutely no chance of it being overturned. I’d be surprised if they extended it by a game though so got to be worth a try.

Agree with this. At the time I thought it was a heavy challenge, the sort that picks up a yellow but there’s no way it will be overturned.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro

 

[DumLum]

Just seen on MOTD I think it's well worth an appeal only looks bad as the Huddersfield player spins round like spinning top and make

Just seen it on Match of The Day myself. I don't know what the pundits made of it as I had the volume down but i think there is no chance of getting that red overturned. Studs showing with a straight leg. I wouldn't want to be on the end of that.

 

[BensGrandad]

Just seen it on Match of The Day myself. I don't know what the pundits made of it as I had the volume down but i think there is no chance of getting that red overturned. Studs showing with a straight leg. I wouldn't want to be on the end of that.

Lampard said definite red Lineker and Murphy said 50/50 CH said 50/50 so I would expect them to appeal it.

 

[Bodian]

Lampard said definite red Lineker and Murphy said 50/50 CH said 50/50 so I would expect them to appeal it.

Hughton said (from the BBC) "On the sending off: "It is down to a referee on the day whether they want to send a player off for that challenge. You will see numerous challenges like that where there are two competitive players. At the time, I thought it was harsh."

That doesn't sound like any appetite to appeal - he's said it's down to the ref on the day, which is precisely what any panel would say.

 

[TSB]

Just be thankful that Duffy didn't go earlier. Clearly a second bookable offence.

VLP fouled Duffy, not the other way around.

 

[BensGrandad]

Hughton said (from the BBC) "On the sending off: "It is down to a referee on the day whether they want to send a player off for that challenge. You will see numerous challenges like that where there are two competitive players. At the time, I thought it was harsh."

That doesn't sound like any appetite to appeal - he's said it's down to the ref on the day, which is precisely what any panel would say.

is that not 50/50? I would think so.