Should Oscar be backed of sacked ?

[My Name Is Gully]

81.73% Backed
18.27% Sacked

Thread starter - are you happy with the democratic result at this stage? Looks so far that most voters can see the longer term and over the whole season!
Hope this helps you in your development and future understanding of football. I continue to learn - amazing huh!

 

[Buzzer]

Come on Buzzer say you what you mean.

Should I be a little less ambiguous?

 

[Ernest]

I'm not going to have a serious discussion with a bloke whose stock in trade is crap homoerotic jokes and shit monotonous threads. You're a boring c unt. You know it, I know it. Now f uck off.

So why do you come on the thread then ?

 

[Buzzer]

So why do you come on the thread then ?

To tell you you're a boring c unt. Think of it as a public service. Not everyone thinks you're a hilarious chappie and no amount of random capitalisation, hilarious mis-spelling or side-splitting homo-erotic japery is going to change that fact. You're a c unt.

 

[Hide albion]

I agree, let the man build his own team. Then cast judgement!

Oscar has done a superb job in his first season, considering abysmal transfer activity by the club and having the squad plagued with injuries right until the final game.

Looking forward to what he can do next season, let's hope he gets the players he needs this time.

 

[Ernest]

To tell you you're a boring c unt. Think of it as a public service. Not everyone thinks you're a hilarious chappie and no amount of random capitalisation, hilarious mis-spelling or side-splitting homo-erotic japery is going to change that fact. You're a c unt.

Thanks for that

 

[tigertim68]

Well, he's dull and uninspiring, but we aren't getting anywhere by sacking managers after one season, especially ones who have been thrown in the deep-end and deserve time to adapt.

he was not thrown in he applied for the job , he must of known what the job entailed

 

[fleet]

Easy back him

 

[Diego Napier]

Didn't you post an Oscar in/out thread a few weeks ago that resulted in a large majority voting retain him and a equally large majority in favour of getting rid of you?

 

[Grombleton]

and neither did getting in any of Barcelona's surplus players

That's not his or the clubs fault though, that's just people putting 2 & 2 together and coming out with 19. Not for the first time, mind.

 

[Ernest]

That's not his or the clubs fault though, that's just people putting 2 & 2 together and coming out with 19. Not for the first time, mind.

Depends if Oscar thought he would be and it was kyboshed by someone else and we ended up with the likes of Obika, Andrews and Lita

 

[Grombleton]

Depends if Oscar thought he would be and it was kyboshed by someone else and we ended up with the likes of Obika, Andrews and Lita

Whilst that is a theoretical possibility, its still only a thought. We'll probably never know the reason behind some duff loan signings - whether its poor scouting, lack of availability of players, lack of fund etc. We can sit here guessing until the cows come home.

 

[Ernest]

Whilst that is a theoretical possibility, its still only a thought. We'll probably never know the reason behind some duff loan signings - whether its poor scouting, lack of availability of players, lack of fund etc. We can sit here guessing until the cows come home.

If we weren't getting Barca reserves etc why then employ a Barca coach ? If the plan was Andrews and other old lags like Lita then someone with knowledge of the English game would have been a better fit ?

Doesn't add up but whatever the reason it has cost us

 

[Grombleton]

If we weren't getting Barca reserves etc why then employ a Barca coach ?

Come on, even you can surely see that's a ridiculous question. We employ a Barcelona coach as he brings the philosophy that the club wanted to, it personally wouldn't matter to me if he came from Barcelona or Rochdale.

Using that theory, should we in future scout the clubs we want the loan signings of, then nick their backroom staff? It's unlikely.

 

[bobby baxter]

If we weren't getting Barca reserves etc why then employ a Barca coach ? If the plan was Andrews and other old lags like Lita then someone with knowledge of the English game would have been a better fit ?

Doesn't add up but whatever the reason it has cost us

The reason we employed a Barca coach was because Oscar played the whole of his career at a world famous football club, was a Spanish international, was a highly regarded coach at Barca and in his first season in management won a title with a club that had spent a decade since their previous win. I thought we were fortunate to get Oscar when we did and have seen nothing to change my mind. If Greer, Upson, Buckley, Crofts and Stephens were available today, we wouldn't have been hammered.

 

[GoldWithFalmer]

The reason we employed a Barca coach was because Oscar played the whole of his career at a world famous football club, was a Spanish international, was a highly regarded coach at Barca and in his first season in management won a title with a club that had spent a decade since their previous win. I thought we were fortunate to get Oscar when we did and have seen nothing to change my mind. If Greer, Upson, Buckley, Crofts and Stephens were available today, we wouldn't have been hammered.

Which would suggest we don't have a strong enough squad.

 

[Seagull on the wing]

- Our manager has got us into the top six (for the second season in a row) in his first season in English football
- We can't be that unlucky with injuries again
- Ince & March have had a season of 1st XI football and will be stronger & better
- CMS back and fit
- one of the best defensive records in the league...again
- New Training Ground with the added benefits that will bring
- A whole summer for Oscar to put his stamp on the squad.

Want any more?

At least some of you are sensible...Jeez,he came in to 9 injuries....and left with 6,what,one season and he hasn't won the title or a play off ? Oh! dear You ,"I want instant success and I want it now" fans have a lot to learn,patience is one of them

 

[TonyW]

Backed, completely.
Genius that has almost got us promoted with a crippling injury crisis.

Really sad to hear that he might be quitting.

 

[Frutos]

Can we sack Ernest instead?

 

[dabadass_209]

I think he failed with the players available to him. We are producing some top talent, but it will all just be top talent for other sides, it's just a matter of time.