Should NAYLOR quit

[Acker79]

I couldn't give a toss if Andy Naylor's an Albion fan or not. In some ways it's better not to have an Albion fan doing the reporting as they're less likely to be partial.

I agree with the sentiment, but the problem people have is that Naylor is not impartial, he is allowing his friendship with micky to colour his reporting, that he reports what the board want reported, not what a neutral would report, and that is, well, scary.

It's nefarious and unsettling when a supposedly impartial third party toes the company line. I want someone who is willing to criticise the club when they're going wrong, because if they don't, how will we know when we have an Archer/Belloti type screwing the club over?

 

[Man of Harveys]

Yeah, but that's exactly what's happened though, innit?

"Exactly"? He's provoked a debate as to whether he should carry on doing his job or not, not on any of the merits of what either he or Attila have said. Which all seems a slightly strange thing for anyone to want to provoke.

 

[clippedgull]

It's quite telling, that since that call JB made to Harty, excepting the 1st half at Cheltenham, the players have performed with 'spirit'. Might have hit a nerve? Maybe Adams should play it before every game!

 

[Black Country Seagull]

It's quite telling, that since that call JB made to Harty, excepting the 1st half at Cheltenham, the players have performed with 'spirit'. Might have hit a nerve? Maybe Adams should play it before every game!

Wonder what the way fans would think to that, It will make the half time talk on the pitch that Hull did this season appear moderate.

 

[bright1064]

The way he worded his piece about JB in the Argus today was bang out of line. Who the hell is Naylor to say things like that? Is he on the payroll of the club or something? I'm tired of his one-sided journalism, it's getting very very boring now.

 

[Les Biehn]

I like Naylor, he gives me hope that one day I too can earn a good wage for doing any old rubbish at work.

 

[Brighton Breezy]

He has done a cracking job at copy and pasting the story about Andrews straight from the South London Press as well...

 

[Black Country Seagull]

He has done a cracking job at copy and pasting the story about Andrews straight from the South London Press as well...

 

[Hannibal smith]

The fact that people like Attila are vociferous in the complaints shows how shit things have been this season. Perfectly sane people are highlighting obvious flaws and not the same old voices of the village idiots. In fact, its only the resident board nut jobs who seem to be blindly behind Adams and his bunch of merry men.

I'm no anti-Naylor in particular but he has dissapeared up his own arse if he thinks that the general mood is that this season is not particualrly different to last and that Attila should walk. Perhaps time for a proper story and give all this bollcoks a rest?

 

[murraymints4brighton]

i think over all he is a poor writer anyway besides all the stupid comments he has mads and we could have someone do a much better job for free.

 

[murraymints4brighton]

hes also copied and pasted a story from some south london paper about andrews.

 

[Deleted member 2719]

Naylor a twat and should F*ck off.

Attilla

 

[les dynam]

The fact that people like Attila are vociferous in the complaints shows how shit things have been this season. Perfectly sane people are highlighting obvious flaws and not the same old voices of the village idiots. In fact, its only the resident board nut jobs who seem to be blindly behind Adams and his bunch of merry men.

I'm no anti-Naylor in particular but he has dissapeared up his own arse if he thinks that the general mood is that this season is not particualrly different to last and that Attila should walk. Perhaps time for a proper story and give all this bollcoks a rest?

that just about covers it for me

 

[Herr Tubthumper]

Employed to toe the party line?

This is Attila we're talking about here. Are you taking the piss?

Incidentally, Nicky Forster called his team's first-half performance against Cheltenham's 'inept'? Should he belt up and toe the party line as well?

What is this 'employed to toe the party' line stuff? Does any one you do this? I certainly dont and am not expected to.

 

[Herr Tubthumper]

By the way Naylor should resign because he is a piss poor reporter.

 

[GNF on Tour]

I hope not as he is very much alive.

Is he? Opps!

 

[ewe2]

Attila and Naylor have voiced ....with passion how they feel ! I respect both for this.Football will win because,this debate creates passions in all of us.Thats why we all love the game.I remember Harty saying ......its a game of opinions.(and we all love the club )

 

[dougdeep]

Yes.

 

[Horney]

Naylor is a prat, pure and simple, Vinicombe must be spinning in his grave.

Is he no longer with us ?

 

[Cheshire Cat]

Just read it...have radio work in London and must dash, but after a few reflective pints in the Star this evening I shall return home and pen a calm, measured and heartfelt reply.

Heartfelt it may be , but calm and measured