Shine or Patience?

[BensGrandad]

Had Patience been made by Robbie Williams, who is a far better singer than Gary Barlow, it would have been a classic.

This song is made for Robbie Williams voice but alas Gary Barlow is no better than the average pub singer.

 

[turienzo's lovechild]

who is a far better singer than Gary Barlow,

no, no, no, NO

 

[jonny.rainbow]

They are both awful.

Patience is slightly less annoying though.

 

[CHAPPERS]

Had Patience been made by Robbie Williams, who is a far better singer than Gary Barlow, it would have been a classic.

It's just a shame that Robbie Williams hasn't got the song writing capabilites of Gary Barlow and sacked the reason why his career went anywhere (the guy he paid to write for him) just before he released the worst album anyone has ever heard, I suppose.

 

[Nibble]

I don't want to get on anyones' tits here but are you really having a serious discussion about which Take That song is better? they are songs written and performed for the gay community and Fourteen year old girls. while they might not be Gay themselves they clearly market themselves for the Gay market and young girls who will look at any vaguely good looking bloke and fancy him.

it has it's place but it isn't good music.

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

Patience - cracking song
Shine - Beatles-esque


Shine edges it for me

 

[rool]

Shine - Beatles-esque

ELO-esque I'd say

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

ELO-esque I'd say

Hey Jude + Mr Blue Sky = Shine

 

[mejonaNO12 aka riskit]

yes!!! a take that poll not started by me! this will piss off EDNA.

both amazing. everything they do is immense and cheesey-brilliance

but...shine is the best pop song for many many years by ANYONE

even mcfly!