Considering your first Albion game was 1994 ( in your profile), how the deuce do you have a view on whether the football or atmosphere was better or worse?.... watching a bit of archive footage or big match highlights doesn't in my view give you the picture you need to make a solid judgement.
I've seen plenty of old football so I can judge by watching it. Re: atmosphere it certainly seems more vibrant back then, and I can remember the North Stand terrace at the Goldstone and how good the atmosphere could be.
Well seeing as most old football I've seen is meant to be representative of the best of football back then, it was PRETTY BAD. Go back to FA Cup final games in the 70s and the defending is immediately hilarious, no positional sense whatsoever, constant miskicks and air kicks, admittedly this is partly due to horrific pitches etc but what you see is still the same.