Munchkin
Well-known member
My point exactly. And branded an idiot by someone that wasn’t even at the game but doesn’t accept the opinion of those that were!
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Schelotto
- Thread starter poidy
- Start date
My point exactly. And branded an idiot by someone that wasn’t even at the game but doesn’t accept the opinion of those that were!
Lush
Mods' Pet
Re Stephens - his new song seems to be the equivalent of the commentators curse
E
Eric Youngs Contact Lense
Guest
A little bit like Tomori when he started with us. Looked very nervous, especially early on, but his contribution grew and eventually he was arguably one of our better attacking threats..
A very very good point. New player looking a bit nervous on his first few appearances shock!
I hate to say it but has Stephens actually been that good at any stage this season? A couple of decent games but really I think he's looked pretty ordinary all season. It is all about opinions but I feel Propper has been very good and has had to cover for Stephens a lot.
Gritt23
New member
Throwing a player under the bus and dismissing them after barely playing any Premier league football is what cost Chelsea players like Salah and De Bruyne. So I'm not going to write the guy off just yet, but I will say that I'm yet to see what he offers that makes him a better option at full back than Rosenoir.
There is some pace there, so he could be an attacking threat down the flank, and he does seem to have a good engine, as I didn't detect him tiring despite putting in a strong shift. But technically, I've not seen anything to get excited about yet, only things to worry about.
There is some pace there, so he could be an attacking threat down the flank, and he does seem to have a good engine, as I didn't detect him tiring despite putting in a strong shift. But technically, I've not seen anything to get excited about yet, only things to worry about.
Sussex Nomad
Well-known member
I shall happily downgrade the 'idiots' to 'many'. Typical post match flash comment, that on reflection is a bit harsh. However I don't get the point of not going. Don't get me wrong I'd loved to and it cost me £90, but hey, at least my mate got to go in my place. Sometimes things at home come first. However I watched it live, all 90 minutes on a stream, so I don't understand how my points are not valid?
RONALDEANO
New member
Last night he was very poor and to me looks like a waste of money, bet then again I said the same about Ryan and was completely off the mark there.
Thought he started off poorly in the first half, but know where near as badly as Huddersfield and grew into the game abit more. His runs in the second half, bombing forward were good and he picked out a great ball for Hemed.
Needs a bit more time to settle before we know if we have a dud or not.
Needs a bit more time to settle before we know if we have a dud or not.
He was alright. Terrible first touch, though - especially when compared to Bruno.
Not sure that's an apt comparison, as Tomori's technique was never in doubt really.
All points are valid as it’s a discussion forum.
However, watching a stream, is different in my opinion, as you cannot see the whole pitch, so consequently do not see positional things or movement.
You are also very reliant on the camera position and producer.
Just an opinion.....[emoji2]
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sussex Nomad
Well-known member
Fair enough, but I would be surprised if, for example, you were just above pitch height behind a goal, if you could see the full picture?
That’s fair comment as well, but personally I haven’t been......... thankfully
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
boik
Well-known member
You don't learn from experience then?
People said Pröpper was a poor signing. People said Ryan was a poor signing.
Let's give Schelotto a decent crack of the whip before writing him off. Even though I know this is NSC's favourite past-time.
I actually think he's going to come good and be an important player for us. We shall see.
Let's give Schelotto a decent crack of the whip before writing him off. Even though I know this is NSC's favourite past-time.
I actually think he's going to come good and be an important player for us. We shall see.
E
Eric Youngs Contact Lense
Guest
..its not really apt to question the technical ability of a player who has played for Inter Milan, Italian senior squad either. Did he show that technical ability last night, maybe not, but the analogy was about starting nervously, looking shaky and improving.. my view of Tomori when he came on last season and my view of Schelotto's performance last night..
The Wookiee
Back From The Dead
Has an Italian defender ever done well in the Premier League ?
HantsSeagull
Well-known member
i am not passing judgement on him as a signing. i was there last night and he was pretty woeful in the first half and started the second half even worse. BUT he did start to look quite good bombing down the wing with knocky. I presume he was brought in to deal with set pieces - which Bruno seems to struggle with.
Jury out for me.
Jury out for me.
nicko31
Well-known member
He's getting better, he needs minutes. We need to lay off him