- Oct 17, 2008
- 15,023
You’ve highlighted a major issue with the application of algorithms full stop. Lots of mathematical modelling, such as the type used here, is exclusively based on static data. I.e using historical data to reach a probable conclusion. “What would likely happen if everything stayed exactly the same”.Saw that so called super computer in some article yesterday predicting next seasons final table. Had us finishing 16th! Who makes these things up I don't know?
But it won’t stay exactly the same. The data is flawed (GIGO) because football like business - probably moreso - is extremely dynamic.
Transfers, managerial changes, injuries, form, refereeing decisions change the original data on a daily, hourly basis making any such calculation outdated immediately.
Plus, you know, it’s football. There are massive outliers every single season because of all the above.
So yeah, we might finish 20th or we might finish 1st - both are very unlikely. This is why these pre-season calculations are generally woefully inaccurate every single season.