Question Time - BBC1 22:45

[portlock seagull]

.....and the shirty guy summarised all that is completely wrong with the hard left - completely intolerant of anyone else's views, completely inflexible regarding his own views and trys to win arguments by simply ranting down opponents at high volume.

And it's telling that the Guardian isn't even reporting this TV highlight yet everyone else does. The guy, called Steve German, is a militant trade unionist. Unless you'd watched the entire show you won't have seen the build up including when he was given a right to reply (he sounded unhinged then) earlier and before he just continually heckled. Dimbleby has never done that before so it tells you what a complete tool the guy was regardless of political views. And taste in shirts!!

 

[portlock seagull]

This is him apparently:

http://www.somersetcountygazette.co...n_candidate_s_conviction_for_criminal_damage/

 

[nicko31]

Gina Miller reminded everyone that 2 years to do Brexit is impossible. A transitional deal is an absolute must, few seem to realise this yet

Some real idiots in the audience this week. If you have a question put your hand up, if you start shouting get out

 

[highflyer]

And it's telling that the Guardian isn't even reporting this TV highlight yet everyone else does. The guy, called Steve German, is a militant trade unionist. Unless you'd watched the entire show you won't have seen the build up including when he was given a right to reply (he sounded unhinged then) earlier and before he just continually heckled. Dimbleby has never done that before so it tells you what a complete tool the guy was regardless of political views. And taste in shirts!!

It was pretty clear he was an idiot and i have no idea why he was given the chance to speak on the basis he was shouting over the panel. That was when I turned off.

Being 'completely intolerant of anyone else's views, completely inflexible regarding his own views and trying to win arguments by simply ranting down opponents at high volume' are not attributes limited to the 'hard left' though? Idiots are idiots, across the political spectrum.

Exhibit A being Donald Trump.

 

[whitelion]

Full marks to Dimbleby for his handling of the shouty man.

 

[clapham_gull]

.....and the shirty guy summarised all that is completely wrong with the hard left - completely intolerant of anyone else's views, completely inflexible regarding his own views and trys to win arguments by simply ranting down opponents at high volume.

Have you listened to anyone on the alt right ?

Sent from my LG-K520 using Tapatalk

 

[pastafarian]

Have you listened to anyone on the alt right ?

Sent from my LG-K520 using Tapatalk

yes i have, loads of them
and they are nowhere near as rude, shouty and confrontational as the type of person so brilliantly personified by shouty mcshoutface on QT last night.
Hope this helps.

 

[cunning fergus]

I see, so this is the narrative that we have always had immigration in the U.K. yes?

When did Ian say that London became a plural city, some time way back in Victorian times I would expect?

Albeit the Guardian indicates it is more recent......

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2007/dec/23/communities.population

We live and learn don't we?

 

[rocker959]

It will be a load of pony! The panel will pussyfoot around the subject won't mention Muslims or the ideology of radical Islam. It will be typical BBC leftism at its glorious best. I wonder if a member of the audience will ask Andy burnham why he shares a platform with MEND. Why not invite Tommy Robinson or Tony Bellew on the show that would even it up a bit.

Correct .

 

[rocker959]

to many do gooders in positions of influence ****ing it up for the majority who can see the light
regards
DR

Totally agree .

 

[Pretty pink fairy]

Totally agree .

sat 24 th june TEN THOUSEND strong march in london. FOOTBALL LADS ALLIANCE organised against extremism in this country, IT'S A START
regards
DR

 

[AmexRuislip]

I may be wrong, isn't QT coming from Hastings soon?

 

[ManOfSussex]

I may be wrong, isn't QT coming from Hastings soon?

Tonight.

 

[AmexRuislip]

Tonight.

Cheers, are you in audience, so I can throw post its at tv

 

[ManOfSussex]

Cheers, are you in audience, so I can throw post its at tv

Sadly not.

It's from The Hastings Centre, which is opposite the hospital on The Ridge. http://www.hastingscentre.co.uk/about/

The panel is:

Liam Fox - Conservative MP
Stella Creasy - Labour MP
Zanny Minton Beddoes - The Economist
Kerry-Anne Mendoza - The Canary
Nick Ferrari - LBC

 

[AmexRuislip]

Sadly not.

It's from The Hastings Centre, which is opposite the hospital on The Ridge. http://www.hastingscentre.co.uk/about/

The panel is:

Liam Fox - Conservative MP
Stella Creasy - Labour MP
Zanny Minton Beddoes - The Economist
Kerry-Anne Mendoza - The Canary
Nick Ferrari - LBC

No Amber Rudd?
She could've got May to stand in for her!
Nick 'on my LBC Radio show' Ferrari will be a hoot.

 

[ManOfSussex]

No Amber Rudd?
She could've got May to stand in for her!
Nick 'on my LBC Radio show' Ferrari will be a hoot.

Last time Amber Rudd turned up at a venue in Hastings 3 weeks back, it reduced her to tears, so perhaps it's best.

 

[knocky1]

sat 24 th june TEN THOUSEND strong march in london. FOOTBALL LADS ALLIANCE organised against extremism in this country, IT'S A START
regards
DR

I thought you'd already started and now thought it was all over.

 

[Beach Hut]

At least David Dimbleby will get home early

 

[Is it PotG?]

Lots of shouting early doors. Whoop whoop.

Nick: I'd sooner have Richard Hammond take me for a Sunday drive than have Corbyn as PM.