From another nation’s perspective, how highly do you rate Maguire as a CB?
Lindelof is the fall guy almost every time ManU concede, on Redcafe and in the media.
I think they are both not good enough if United wants to become this über-mega powerful club again. It is difficult times to be a defender though, their roles have changed a lot in only the ca 18 months since the goal kick rule change. Not only do they need to be technically competent themselves, they also have to defend against far more thought-through attack ideas than the "lump it up and see what happens" that a lot of teams used to go with.