Change at Barnham
Well-known member
How can any one not enjoy watching Brighton play? The only thing that's been missing is a few more wins.
Potter In!
Potter In!
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] Potter In or Out
- Thread starter Icy Gull
- Start date
Agreed . . .I don't remember arguing in the pub about Team Brady/Case/Dinner lady/Gritt in the 90's it was universally agreed most of us on the teraces were better players and better (or at least regularly) paid!, it was all about club survival. How times change.
Yeah really looked like it. One of our best comebacks in years, great spirit. If there was an issue with morale or the manager those are the games you lose 3, 4 or 5-1.
You could see the togetherness when we equalised.
Name your source sir, or I call BS.
If you are referring to Potter losing Matty Ryan, I think you are correct.
Clive Walker
Stand Or Fall
I'd counter that by saying the 2nd half was more a response from the dressing room and not the manager.
Nonsense. It’s the opposite.
If the players hate the manager they would have conveniently lost that one heavily to get him the boot.
London Irish
Well-known member
I see debate is not for you, I'll remember that in future
London Irish
Well-known member
It's Potter's only "achievement" - he's absolutely gutted expectation levels among fans and it's sad to see. Many of us want to stay at this level but some are throwing in the towel and think life would be better in the Championship
London Irish
Well-known member
The irony of someone posting a white flag when they've previously said they'd be perfectly happy to support Potter as our coach in the Championship. *Chef's kiss*
Icy Gull
Back on the rollercoaster
- Jul 5, 2003
- 72,015
- Thread starter
- #311
No they are not. Most, who support him long term, are saying that they will take a relegation on the way if it comes to it. They do not accept that we are relegated already. It sounds like your towel is in mid flight and will only be grabbed back if we sack him and replace him with....well anybody it seems
Clive Walker
Stand Or Fall
No what I am saying is that the players are fighting for themselves not for the manager. They don't want to fail because they have lost faith in the manager. Thats the kind of thing I am hearing anyway from a person speaking directly to those in the dressing room.
London Irish
Well-known member
I have never said I’d be perfectly happy
You have definitely started waving it from recent posts though.
Let's lose the perfectly happy then. Can you clarify that you definitely want Potter to stay as manager if we get relegated? yes or no? I'm not imagining things am I? You said that?
My case is those who favour this option have just abandoned any performance standards whatsoever for this season, no doubt out of sheer demoralisation at our results
London Irish
Well-known member
Fair play I forgot Sanchez. Alzate is a real head scratcher, why blood him in all those games last season but give him so few games this? Sanchez alas throws up another troubling issue of the catastrophic loss of form under Potter of many of our Premier League stalwarts
Icy Gull
Back on the rollercoaster
- Jul 5, 2003
- 72,015
- Thread starter
- #316
Yes, I want Potter to stay, even if we go down. I have seen enough of how he wants to play the game to give him time. So far I seem to be on the same page as TB but I would never try and second guess his intentions when push comes to shove.
I have enjoyed the football under Potter and THINK that I can see that it will work if given time and backing. I could of course be wrong and we could do a Pompey or Sunderland but I don’t think we will.
We have been in just about every game right to the final whistle, so we are not far short of what’s needed. Just my opinion and I get, but disagree, with those who think a change of manager will make a difference long term
I should just add that this season has been the most frustrating in my many years of following the Albion but no I’m certainly not demoralised
Last edited:
Justice
Dangerous Idiot
Have you ever played football at a decent level? Your manager sets up the team tells what to do not what to do once players see it’s not working they soon start to question the tactics. Your also getting digs out on the pitch from the opposition telling you how crap you are.Yes, I want Potter to stay, even if we go down. I have seen enough of how he wants to play the game to give him time. So far I seem to be on the same page as TB but I would never try and second guess his intentions when push comes to shove.
I have enjoyed the football under Potter and THINK that I can see that it will work if given time and backing. I could of course be wrong and we could do a Pompey or Sunderland but I don’t think we will.
We have been in just about every game right to the final whistle, so we are not far short of what’s needed. Just my opinion and I get, but disagree, with those who think a change of manager will make a difference long term
A new manager could easily change the run of form with fresh ideas and tactics without changing the structure of the club. I know you think Potter is the bees knees although you have to agree he’s made some pretty basic mistakes for a so called PL manager.
Icy Gull
Back on the rollercoaster
- Jul 5, 2003
- 72,015
- Thread starter
- #318
Suggest the players have made the mistakes more often than the manager. Pointless arguing this as there is no way of knowing who is right unless he is sacked. Off the top of my head sticking with Ferguson and Dyche worked, so there is mileage in being behind sticking with some managers. Anyway I was just answering a question from [MENTION=1483]London Irish[/MENTION]. I do not expect anyone to change their opinion on what I think though.
Yes, I want Potter to stay, even if we go down. I have seen enough of how he wants to play the game to give him time. So far I seem to be on the same page as TB but I would never try and second guess his intentions when push comes to shove.
I have enjoyed the football under Potter and THINK that I can see that it will work if given time and backing. I could of course be wrong and we could do a Pompey or Sunderland but I don’t think we will.
We have been in just about every game right to the final whistle, so we are not far short of what’s needed. Just my opinion and I get, but disagree, with those who think a change of manager will make a difference long term
I should just add that this season has been the most frustrating in my many years of following the Albion but no I’m certainly not demoralised
That's an honest response and I understand why you are looking at what sits behind the games and seeing potential. I get that.
In response, from the other side of the fence, I feel that data is inaccurate. Our xG is higher - in the case of the Wolves game, higher than theirs - and yet we are not seeing results go our way, and this is the consistent picture over the past year.
I don't think TB is going to make a change now because I don't think TB thinks a change will change things at this stage of the season. I think that any manager TB might want would simply not move now. After all, who is going to move during the middle of this season while we are in the midst of a pandemic. The managers TB might want are probably already employed and are unlikely to up sticks. So support for GP from TB should not be seen as support for the results to date.
All the said and done, I desperately want GP to be a success. I think most of us in the OUT camp would say the same. We're not anti-GP but aware of his short comings and concerned that he will take us down.
Personally, I don't think GP alone is to blame. He needs a striker and the board should have acted on this sooner. It's a mistake and knowing this board they'll admit it privately but never publicly. They are a tad too proud.
Perhaps Zeqiri is the answer, or one of our other signings that we sent out on loan, but again that was a mistake.
TB and the management team have done a brilliant job over the past few years and they have our full support. Even a brilliant team make strategic errors. We've made one.
If GP gets his striker we might stay up, but that won't explain away some of the naive selections and tactical set ups GP has made.
Let's hope that in a year's time you are right and we're in the top half of the Premier League. I hope so.
Something else Big Sam claims is making it tougher is the new Brexit rules.
Football manager who voted Leave complains about not being able to sign players because of Brexit
He is quoted as saying: “I have found three players already who were capable of coming here and they're not allowed. It's a shame. Due to the new regulations in terms of the permit they were unable to come to this country, whereas (previously) they would have done. I have to look at that and think 'can he qualify?'
https://www.msn.com/en-gb/sport/american-football/football-manager-who-voted-leave-complains-about-not-being-able-to-sign-players-because-of-brexit/ar-BB1csxmF
Apparently Pro-Brexit campaigner Big Sam has just found out what he voted for
Its weird... wonder what junk he was looking to sign then. If you read the new work permit rules they are far more lenient than they were before unless you are trying to sign U18 players. Before it was "if you come from some country where they eat mango and shit you better be good...", now its more "if you are reliably existing, please come".