Player ratings

[goldstone]

Flinders 6. A couple of good saves, but looked dodgy in the second half when he failed to come for balls. Bring back Kuipers.

O'Ceaurill 5. RB is not his position ... so Wendy, listen up ... DO NOT PLAY HIM THERE.

Lynch 8. Excellent game. He's getting better with every game.

Butters 7. Outjumped a few times and caught for pace once in the first half. A good game, but not his best.

ElAbd 8. Great game.

Bertin 8. Class.

Hammond 7. Played well.

Robinson 5. Poor. Lack of anticipation, poor ball control.

Cox 6. Better than some of his recent form. One or two good corners towards the end, but some crap ones earlier on.

Revell 6. Ran and ran, but not yet back to his best.

Savage 7. Good game and well taken goal, but would like to see him spending less time on the wing.


Sub: Gatting 5. What was the point?


Message for Wilkins:
1. Gary Hart probably should have started at RB. At least he should have been on the bench and been brought on for Jake midway through the second ha;f.
2. O'Ceaurill is NOT a RB. He is a liability in that position.
3. Kuipers should be back in goal.

 

[Beach Hut]

Flinders 7
O'Ceaurill 8
Lynch 8
Butters 7
ElAbd 6
Bertin 9
Hammond 8
Robinson 6
Cox 7
Revell 7
Savage 8

Sub: Gatting 4

 

[goldstone]

Flinders 7
O'Ceaurill 8
Lynch 8
Butters 7
ElAbd 6
Bertin 9
Hammond 8
Robinson 6
Cox 7
Revell 7
Savage 8

Sub: Gatting 4

Were you watching the same game? What exactly did O'Ceaurill do to deserve an 8?

 

[1066gull]

Flinders 8
O'Ceaurill 7
Lynch 7
Butters 7
ElAbd 6
Bertin 9
Hammond 8
Robinson 7
Cox 7
Revell 6
Savage 9

Sub: Gatting 5

Wanted to see Elder on

 

[Beach Hut]

Were you watching the same game? What exactly did O'Ceaurill do to deserve an 8?

If memory serves me correct a superb block, however I stand to be corrected

 

[goldstone]

If memory serves me correct a superb block, however I stand to be corrected

Sorry, you're correct, he did make a super block. The rest of the time he was mostly crap and deserved a low rating.

 

[ali jenkins]

Flinders 7- Looked very dodgey coming for balls into the box but made a good save in the second half.

O'Ceaurill 6- at fault for the goal i felt but made a good block and a superb tackle in the box that would have been a pen if he messed it up!

Lynch 8- had a good game today, his pace saved us a few times.

Butters 8- also had a good game, not his best but we needed his experiance!

ElAbd 7- typical full blooded challenges again.

Bertin 8- not sure if he deserved MOM but was one of our best players.

Hammond 8- led by example.

Robinson 8- played well in his new role, had some good scoring chances aswell.

Cox 8- some good positions out wide and a few good balls into the box.

Revell 8- same old same old from revelldiniho, still not 100%fit yet though.

Savage 8- Good goal and a good battling game, still not 100% hes an acctuall footballer though!

Sub: Gatting - I got bored by this point!

 

[adammicheal]

Flinders 6. A couple of good saves, but looked dodgy in the second half when he failed to come for balls. Bring back Kuipers.
3. Kuipers should be back in goal.

Can i have some of the drugs that you are on please?

The last 3 games now Flinders has been quality, INHO definate 1st choice for Palace next season and a very bright future in front of him

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Flinders 8
O'Ceaurill 5
Lynch 7
Butters 7
El Abd 7
Bertin 9
Hammond 8
Robinson 4
Cox 8
Revell 7
Savage 8

Slow Joe 2

 

[O Lads]

Re: Re: Player ratings

Can i have some of the drugs that you are on please?

The last 3 games now Flinders has been quality, INHO definate 1st choice for Palace next season and a very bright future in front of him

Agreed, on all counts.

 

[Pettitt303]

Flinders 7- Looked very dodgey coming for balls into the box but made a good save in the second half.

O'Ceaurill 6- at fault for the goal i felt but made a good block and a superb tackle in the box that would have been a pen if he messed it up!

Lynch 8- had a good game today, his pace saved us a few times.

Butters 8- also had a good game, not his best but we needed his experiance!

ElAbd 7- typical full blooded challenges again.

Bertin 8- not sure if he deserved MOM but was one of our best players.

Hammond 8- led by example.

Robinson 8- played well in his new role, had some good scoring chances aswell.

Cox 8- some good positions out wide and a few good balls into the box.

Revell 8- same old same old from revelldiniho, still not 100%fit yet though.

Savage 8- Good goal and a good battling game, still not 100% hes an acctuall footballer though!

Sub: Gatting - I got bored by this point!

Are you mad...Robinson 8!!!!

I would give him about a 4 , done absoluetly nothing . I would rather have Revell playing behind the front two and Elder up front with Bas.

 

[Spunk Bubble]

When will Wilkins start Elder. FOR GODS SAKE !!!!!

 

[dougdeep]

All 7, except El Abd 8 and Robinson 6.

 

[Withdean Wanderer]

Flinders 6 - some indecision, one very good save.
El-Abd 8 - Considering his position he was fantastic.
Lynch 7 - strong, they didn't get past him.
Butters - 7 - Solid, strong - one ridiculously dirty tackle late on
O'Ceaurill - 5 - Cost us a goal but saved another with a good block. Not a right back though Wilkins.
Cox - 6 - good on the right, rubbish on the left
Bertin - 7 - was ok, gave the ball away a suprising amount though. Didn't create much
Hammond - 6 - looked injured. Very quiet
Robinson - 5 - out of position, did nothing until the second half
Savage - 8 - excellent goal, excelland celebration. Good all round performance
Revell - 6- still not quite there in terms of performance or fitness

Gatting - 5
Loft - 10

 

[SeagullTim]

Flinders 7
El-Abd 6
Lynch 7
Butters 7
O'Ceaurill 6
Cox 7
Bertin 8
Hammond 7
Robinson 6
Savage 7
Revell 7

Gatting 5 - Why? It should have been Elder IMO

 

[Loft23]

Flinders 7
El-Abd 7
Lynch 7
Butters 7
O'Cearuill 6
Bertin 8
Hammond 7
Cox 7
Robinson 6
Savage 8
Revell 7

Gatting 5

 

[Trigger]

As rare as the queen popping round your house for a white dogshit sandwich was the sight of me at Withdean yesterday...



Flinders 6
O'Ceaurill 6
Lynch 7
Butters 7
El Abd 7
Bertin 8
Hammond 7
Robinson 5
Cox 7
Revell 6
Savage 11

Gatting 5

 

[Napper]

dunno how the goal was anyones fault really , thought the bloke showed a bit of quality above league 1 standard..... these things happen