I'm pretty sure it was Barnes who mis-kicked.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Player Ratings vs Millwall
- Thread starter BUTTERBALL
- Start date
I'm pretty sure it was Barnes who mis-kicked.
chez
Johnny Byrne-The Greatest
I tend to agree with all of these comments but would drop them all a point. On tonights performance I dont believe anybody deserved a 7.
On the plus side, if we can play that bad and get a point we must be doing something right.
clippedgull
Hotdogs, extra onions
I'm not 100 per cent sure.
Weststander
Well-known member
You know your football. Navarro, CMS, Dunk, Jara, Bridcutt were so poor tonight.
Brezovan 5
Calderon 6
Greer 4
Dunk 3
Mattock 5
Bridcutt 5
Barnes 7
Navarro 3
Reyes 5
Vokes 7
CMS 4
Subs
Noone 5
Agdestein 7
Lua Lua 7 - just for the goal
Barnes and Vokes were the only two who could hold their heads up after that (and Agdestein too, this guy is really promising). That was the worst performance I've seen from Dunk - did he pass to a Brighton player all night?
Must say that I thought Millwall were one of the best teams I've seen at the Amex - how the hell are they near the bottom?
Calderon 6
Greer 4
Dunk 3
Mattock 5
Bridcutt 5
Barnes 7
Navarro 3
Reyes 5
Vokes 7
CMS 4
Subs
Noone 5
Agdestein 7
Lua Lua 7 - just for the goal
Barnes and Vokes were the only two who could hold their heads up after that (and Agdestein too, this guy is really promising). That was the worst performance I've seen from Dunk - did he pass to a Brighton player all night?
Must say that I thought Millwall were one of the best teams I've seen at the Amex - how the hell are they near the bottom?
It was an easy cross to catch, if a keeper can't catch, he should look for a bloody career doing something else.
That was a bloody bread and butter catch but he punched it clear which led to the goal !
The Lemming Stomper
Under the flag
i know it's all about opinions, but...c'mon !!!
I thought it was Navarro myself but not sure. Either way, that was a rare occasion when I felt the punch was the right thing to do. It was a hideous miskick by Navarro/Barnes that caused that goal, not the punch.
Super Steve Earle
Well-known member
And these are the correct ratings.
Brez cocked up the punch (more of a flap), then Navarro mis kicked his clearance back into the danger zone.
Greer and Dunk were very poor tonight.
Felt sorry for CMS. Play him upfront or not at all.
and why no wide men for a home match against a struggling team? so many wasted crosses by Calde.
andybaha
Active member
I'm going to be far less generous.
Brezovan - 5- Didn't command tonight
Calderon - 5- OK going forward but limited defensively
Greer -5- Not his best night
Dunk -4- Perhaps he needed a another couple of days to get over his virus
Mattock - 5- He let Feeney get a cross in far too many times.
Bridcutt - 5- Didn't seem to know what he was meant to be doing tonight
Navarro - 4 - He will be embarrassed to collect his bottle of bubbly.
Reyes - 4 - Not a midfielder
Barnes - 5 - Not as bad as some
CMS - 5 - Had a hand in the first goal
Vokes - 6 - Could be a good acquisition if given the service
Toby - 5 - Did his bit but probably doesn't think he's a winger
Noone - 5 - Caused a bit of panic and they put two players on him
Lua Lua - 6 - Salvaged a barely deserved point.
Gus - Got it all horribly wrong tonight. We can't rotate the squad like Man U, the players are not good enough and too many were out of position. We missed El Abd's aggression and enthusiasm.
Brezovan - 5- Didn't command tonight
Calderon - 5- OK going forward but limited defensively
Greer -5- Not his best night
Dunk -4- Perhaps he needed a another couple of days to get over his virus
Mattock - 5- He let Feeney get a cross in far too many times.
Bridcutt - 5- Didn't seem to know what he was meant to be doing tonight
Navarro - 4 - He will be embarrassed to collect his bottle of bubbly.
Reyes - 4 - Not a midfielder
Barnes - 5 - Not as bad as some
CMS - 5 - Had a hand in the first goal
Vokes - 6 - Could be a good acquisition if given the service
Toby - 5 - Did his bit but probably doesn't think he's a winger
Noone - 5 - Caused a bit of panic and they put two players on him
Lua Lua - 6 - Salvaged a barely deserved point.
Gus - Got it all horribly wrong tonight. We can't rotate the squad like Man U, the players are not good enough and too many were out of position. We missed El Abd's aggression and enthusiasm.
pishhead
Well-known member
Brezovan - 4 at fault for the first goal, he hasn't punched it in such a manner since he has been recalled.
Calde - 7 The closest thing to an outlet in the first half.
Mattock - 6 Looks decent.
Dunk/Greer - 5 Both poor by their standards, El Abd would've been better to deal with the dangerous runs off Trotter
Bridcutt - 5 Poor by his exceptionally high standards
Navarro - 6 Average game, capped by his family voting him MOM
Reyes - 5 Tried too hard to force the play.
Barnes - 7 Decent game in my opinion, worked hard and showed up with some decent hold up play.
CMS - 5 Really not up to it today, touch was poor.
Vokes - 7 Held up the ball well and won balls in the air, could be a decent outlet.
Lua-Lua - 7 For the goal alone
Agdestein - 6 Looked good to start with, spooned one effort and then confidence went.
Noone - 5 Didn't get involved enough.
Calde - 7 The closest thing to an outlet in the first half.
Mattock - 6 Looks decent.
Dunk/Greer - 5 Both poor by their standards, El Abd would've been better to deal with the dangerous runs off Trotter
Bridcutt - 5 Poor by his exceptionally high standards
Navarro - 6 Average game, capped by his family voting him MOM
Reyes - 5 Tried too hard to force the play.
Barnes - 7 Decent game in my opinion, worked hard and showed up with some decent hold up play.
CMS - 5 Really not up to it today, touch was poor.
Vokes - 7 Held up the ball well and won balls in the air, could be a decent outlet.
Lua-Lua - 7 For the goal alone
Agdestein - 6 Looked good to start with, spooned one effort and then confidence went.
Noone - 5 Didn't get involved enough.
Ninja Elephant
Doctor Elephant
- Feb 16, 2009
- 18,855
Brezovan 6 - He is what he is. We know what he's good at, and what he isn't. Tonight shouldn't suprise anyone.
Calderon 6 - In the team for no obvious reason, couple of good crosses first half though.
Mattock 7 - Quality player, rarely beaten on his wing and likes to get forward too.
Greer 6 - Striding forward but without any real intent, no problems really with Henderson.
Dunk 6 - Odd to bring him back after El-Abd's performance at Leeds, but did ok.
Bridcutt 6 - Not his best game, but it's stupid having 3 holding midfielders, no space for any of them.
Navarro 6 - Man of the match? After his assist for the opener? Good shot which led to our goal though.
Jara 5 - Backheel was class, the rest of his night wasn't. Should be automatic choice at right back.
Barnes 7 - Graft, hard work and looked better than usual on the ball. Wild shooting though.
Mackail-Smith 6 - Not happening at home, but the system is getting less and less out of him.
Vokes 7 - Good goal and general play, he looks a lot better than we've had for a while.
Subs
Agdestein 7 - Looked good, but can't finish. Put in some good crosses though.
Noone 6 - Never in the game, and seemed to finish up front... Daft and pointless.
LuaLua 7 - Cracking goal, his only contribution but I'm happy enough with that.
The formation was bizarre and Gus is to blame for that, very strange night in general.
Calderon 6 - In the team for no obvious reason, couple of good crosses first half though.
Mattock 7 - Quality player, rarely beaten on his wing and likes to get forward too.
Greer 6 - Striding forward but without any real intent, no problems really with Henderson.
Dunk 6 - Odd to bring him back after El-Abd's performance at Leeds, but did ok.
Bridcutt 6 - Not his best game, but it's stupid having 3 holding midfielders, no space for any of them.
Navarro 6 - Man of the match? After his assist for the opener? Good shot which led to our goal though.
Jara 5 - Backheel was class, the rest of his night wasn't. Should be automatic choice at right back.
Barnes 7 - Graft, hard work and looked better than usual on the ball. Wild shooting though.
Mackail-Smith 6 - Not happening at home, but the system is getting less and less out of him.
Vokes 7 - Good goal and general play, he looks a lot better than we've had for a while.
Subs
Agdestein 7 - Looked good, but can't finish. Put in some good crosses though.
Noone 6 - Never in the game, and seemed to finish up front... Daft and pointless.
LuaLua 7 - Cracking goal, his only contribution but I'm happy enough with that.
The formation was bizarre and Gus is to blame for that, very strange night in general.
I find it hard to be harsh on the players (so I won't bother scoring our defense) and Gus always says it's his fault if things go wrong because the players do what he tells them. Gus got it wrong tonight, I am very pleased we weren't playing anyone better than Millwall.
They don't usually get as much help from the other team I'd imagine.
They don't usually get as much help from the other team I'd imagine.
Last edited:
Seagull1989
Well-known member
- Oct 31, 2011
- 1,204
Brezovan - 6 - flapped a bit at first goal. Almost made a howler rolling the ball out.
Calderon -6 - had a number of chances to cross. Delivery could have been better.
Dunk- 4 - poor distribution
Greer - 3 - uncomposed
Mattock - 2- skinned every time down the wing
Reyes - 4 - poor passing
Bridcutt - 3 - trotter bossed the game
Navarro -3- needed to get stuck in
Cms- 4- lot of running no end product
Barnes -6- linked up well with vokes. Couple of half chances
Vokes -7- a real handful. MOTM
Calderon -6 - had a number of chances to cross. Delivery could have been better.
Dunk- 4 - poor distribution
Greer - 3 - uncomposed
Mattock - 2- skinned every time down the wing
Reyes - 4 - poor passing
Bridcutt - 3 - trotter bossed the game
Navarro -3- needed to get stuck in
Cms- 4- lot of running no end product
Barnes -6- linked up well with vokes. Couple of half chances
Vokes -7- a real handful. MOTM
Gazwag
5 millionth post poster
His poor punch went straight to our player who didn't have chance to clear it because it was in him too quick. Brez fault I'm afraid.
ferring seagull
Well-known member
- Dec 30, 2010
- 4,607
Wont disagree with most of that but Navs may as well have side footed the ball into our net instead of just passing it to the opposing forward. Sorry but, apart from that, his passing was woeful !
chez
Johnny Byrne-The Greatest
Personally I dont think he punched it clear at all, but even if he did it would have been much better to have caught it and lets face it any keeper in the league should have been able to catch that cross.
That's a f*** up at Leeds that didn't cost us and a f*** up tonight that did. Time for Gonzalez to be given a chance I think.
chez
Johnny Byrne-The Greatest
I thought Millwll were one of the worst teams weve seen down here this season, I think it was us that made them look good at times. Saying that their No 5 had a very good game.
Yep! Time for brez to go in the stand sit next to Casper and watch Gonzalez show them both how it's done