Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Player ratings vs Derby
- Thread starter BHA123456
- Start date
Barnes -7 (SEVEN) - (MINUS). Awful. Better off playing with ten men. At least the eliminated man can't give the ball away every time he gets it. Happened multiple times today, poor touch allowed them to break through the middle a number of times. Not a midfielder, not a left winger, not good enough to play up top on his own in our formation.
- Thread starter
- #3
I was listening to the game on the radio, and Barnes name got mentioned about 3 times, all of which were for half chances that he had blown. Sounded alarmingly quite, starting to become a similar story.
TK - 7
Bruno - 7
Greer - 6
El-Abd - 6
Bridge - 6
Bridcutt - 8
Dicker - 6
Lopez - 6
Buckley - 6
Orlandi - 5
Barnes - 5
Dobbie - 6
Hammond - 6
Bruno - 7
Greer - 6
El-Abd - 6
Bridge - 6
Bridcutt - 8
Dicker - 6
Lopez - 6
Buckley - 6
Orlandi - 5
Barnes - 5
Dobbie - 6
Hammond - 6
Great vide printer analogy. On the last couple of games evidence would be better of plying his trade in the highland league for Inverurie Locomotive works than the mighty stripes.
His thickness at times astounds me.
Genuinely better as a supporting striker/offensive player when he has literally no time to think before finishing with aplomb.
How many times does Gus need to see that sort of display to learn he's not a chuffing midfielder?
One word: GASH.
His thickness at times astounds me.
Genuinely better as a supporting striker/offensive player when he has literally no time to think before finishing with aplomb.
How many times does Gus need to see that sort of display to learn he's not a chuffing midfielder?
One word: GASH.
Mr Burns
New member
What you talking about. Barnes is miles better than Murray and 90% of NSC thought hes better than CMS. Must of just had an off day.
Who are you talking about?
- Thread starter
- #8
What you talking about. Barnes is miles better than Murray and 90% of NSC thought hes better than CMS. Must of just had an off day.
I agree, Barnes is a great player. But the last 3/4 games, Barnes has been no where near where he should be. I see Barnes as a vital player in the sqaud, but he is becoming to realize that his space in the starting 11 isnt at any danger at the moment. He is not putting in as much effort as he was when CMS, Hosking etc was fit.
pork pie
New member
Were you actually at the game?
PIG was outstanding, Bruno. Bridge and Bridcutt were ok. Others were distinctly average, with the exception of Dobbie who was a spineless, useless, waste of space.
Washie
Well-known member
I think he's being sarcastic, as i've never seen him say anything good about Barnes.
Mr Burns
New member
You obviosuly missed what I said about him after the Barnsley game then. Give it another season, I'm sure he'll have good game within a year.
No player on that pitch was outstanding today. PIG did everything he was asked to do very well but didnt have that much to actually do. 2 good saves in the second half but you would expect any decent keeper to make them. Personally I thought Bridcutt was our best player, he continually broke up their play and tried to drive us forward.
And that is a ridiculous comment about Dobbie. He was the only player who looked anywhere near capable of creating something for us but he had no help from Barnes, Orlandi or Lopez. Were you one of the fans shouting for him to f*** off back to Swansea in the second half then?
pork pie
New member
Well, apart from the two outstanding saves in two minutes... ... ... lol
No I was not shouting at Dobbie, but clearly they saw the same as me and my friends.
you must be referring to John. I understand now
albionalex
Well-known member
Kuszczak - 7- Not much to do but made 2 excellent saves towards the end.
Bruno - 7- Popped up all over the place and defended well.
Greer - 6- tidy game
El-Abd - 4- distribution was awful and was caught out in defence often
Bridge - 6- defended well but lacked the killer ball in final 3rd
Dicker - 5- at times his first touch and passing was atrocious.
Bridcutt - 6- Sloppy on the ball but tackled well. Chose to pass when he had a clear shot at goal and then chose to shoot when in better position to pass.
Lopez - 5- far too quiet but everything he did, he did well. Should have hit the target but blazed over.
Orlandi - 5- Not really in the game and looked lightweight.
Barnes - 5- Looked very slow and laboured. A few nice passes and flicks.
Buckley - 5- Didn't influence the game before he went off.
Hammond - 4- Poor passing and nearly gave a goal away.
Dobbie - 6- Looked uncomfortable up top but made some superb flicks and runs.
Bruno - 7- Popped up all over the place and defended well.
Greer - 6- tidy game
El-Abd - 4- distribution was awful and was caught out in defence often
Bridge - 6- defended well but lacked the killer ball in final 3rd
Dicker - 5- at times his first touch and passing was atrocious.
Bridcutt - 6- Sloppy on the ball but tackled well. Chose to pass when he had a clear shot at goal and then chose to shoot when in better position to pass.
Lopez - 5- far too quiet but everything he did, he did well. Should have hit the target but blazed over.
Orlandi - 5- Not really in the game and looked lightweight.
Barnes - 5- Looked very slow and laboured. A few nice passes and flicks.
Buckley - 5- Didn't influence the game before he went off.
Hammond - 4- Poor passing and nearly gave a goal away.
Dobbie - 6- Looked uncomfortable up top but made some superb flicks and runs.
The Terminator
New member
- Aug 7, 2010
- 1,419
Thought barnes looked okay, done decent with the service he got. Dobbie was horrendous, looked lazy and made the wrong runs. He is defiantly not a striker. We looked a lot better than the previous two game, Bruno have a positive impact. When CMS and Crofts are back we will start seeing better performances.
classic!! they said on radio that he was MOM.
Gotta love the way people see the game differently.
seagullsovergrimsby
#cpfctinpotclub
Kuszczak 7
Bruno 7
Greer 6
ElAbd 6
Bridge 6
Dicker 5
Bridcutt 7
Lopez 5
Orlandi 5
Barnes 5
Buckley 6
subs
Dobbie 5
Hammond 5
My MOM was Bruno
Bruno 7
Greer 6
ElAbd 6
Bridge 6
Dicker 5
Bridcutt 7
Lopez 5
Orlandi 5
Barnes 5
Buckley 6
subs
Dobbie 5
Hammond 5
My MOM was Bruno